Covid Commission: the Federation of Medical Associations also contests the methods used in the hearings

The Federation of Medical Associations supports the demands of the 255 scientists and is calling for guarantees regarding the conduct of the hearings. Lisei and Malan accuse the signatories of seeking to shield the experts from questioning, but the document asserts Parliament’s right to investigate errors and determine responsibility. 

18 NOV 26
Translated by AI
(Photo: Getty)

(Photo: Getty)

I signed the letter that, on 17 November, 255 scientists and healthcare professionals addressed to the Presidents of the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate, calling for action regarding the conduct of the parliamentary inquiry into Covid and the respect due to those being questioned and to scientific expertise. Decisions taken during the pandemic must be assessed on the basis of the knowledge available at the time they were taken.
The first institutional endorsement came from the Turin Medical Association, a public body with around 17,600 members, whose Executive Council resolved to sign the document. The request has now reached the National Federation of Medical, Surgical and Dental Associations (FNOMCeO), whose Central Committee unanimously approved a motion reinforcing and emphasising its contents. The FNOMCeO represents almost half a million members – around 488,000 – of whom over 423,000 are doctors, and has addressed the same recipients – the Presidents of the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate – asking them to ensure that the dignity of individuals and respect for scientific expertise are upheld during the hearings.
The Federation reiterates the criteria already set out for assessing decisions taken during the pandemic. It states that “no decision can be exempt from scrutiny and no responsibility from its legitimate assessment”, specifying that this process must take into account the scientific knowledge available at the time the decisions were made. It commemorates the 385 doctors and dentists who died during the pandemic and hopes that "the memory of the pandemic does not become a source of division", thereby helping to prepare the country for future health emergencies.
Prior to 17 November, five scientific societies – SIAARTI, SIMEU, SIMI, SIMIT and SITA – had issued statements; these represent anaesthetists and resuscitators, emergency doctors, internists and specialists in infectious diseases and anti-infective therapy; SIAARTI and SIMI alone have over 14,000 members. Among the 255 signatories are a Nobel laureate, five members of the Accademia dei Lincei, over a hundred full professors and senior consultants, alongside Stefano Paglia of Codogno Hospital, Roberto Cosentini of the Papa Giovanni XXIII Hospital in Bergamo and Francesco Castelli of the Spedali Civili in Brescia. This was followed by the formal endorsement of the Italian Society of Hygiene, Preventive Medicine and Public Health (SItI), an appeal by scientists to the Quirinale and a petition which gathered over a thousand signatures in just a few hours.
The responses received from the parliamentary majority do not address the substance of the requests. The Committee Chair, Marco Lisei, stated: “It is very serious that, amongst some scientists, there is a pervasive notion that holding those with institutional responsibilities to account for their decisions could be seen as an attack on science.” Lisei cited Silvio Garattini as an example of a scientist who had answered the questions without feeling under attack. Garattini signed the document dated 17 November following his hearing. Lucio Malan, leader of the Fratelli d’Italia group in the Senate, wrote on X on 17 November: “The more the Covid Commission highlights irregularities, measures taken without scientific basis, and multi-million deals involving figures close to the left, the more the artillery of those defending all this is unleashed. Now they are arguing that scientists cannot be asked questions. As I said in the Commission during Professor Rezza’s hearing: as experts in the field, they are expected to be able to explain the basis for their claims.”
The requests for action addressed to the Speakers of the Chambers come from the FNOMCeO, whose Central Committee voted unanimously in favour, and from the Turin Medical Association, which has resolved to support the motion. Tenders, face masks and monoclonal antibodies are not the subject of the objections, which concern the procedures for the hearings and the assessment of scientific evidence. Among other things, it is requested that the investigation should cover the responsibilities of the regions, which are responsible for organising the majority of healthcare provision.
No one has claimed that scientists cannot be asked questions. The document sent to Parliament states: “Parliament certainly has every right to investigate the management of the pandemic, in order to ascertain any errors committed and the associated responsibilities, including political ones.” Giorgio Parisi, Silvio Garattini and Nino Cartabellotta answered the Commission’s questions and signed the document. What is contested, however, are the allegations “fabricated without taking into account the answers provided”, including on issues for which the Committee had already obtained scientific reports – including those by Parisi – which were subsequently raised again without reference to the explanations already received.
The obligation referred to by Malan to explain the basis for one’s assertions also applies to the commissioners. In the Commission’s work, reports of suspected adverse events were treated as reactions caused by vaccines. In pharmacovigilance, a report records an event occurring following administration; to establish a causal link, it is necessary to assess possible alternative explanations and, where appropriate, compare the observed rates with those expected in the population. At a hearing on 6 November, a clause in an advance purchase agreement was used to argue that the vaccine’s efficacy was unknown at the time of authorisation, which was granted following the evaluation of clinical trials. The public use of claims that had yet to be verified had already been challenged by Licia Ronzulli, Stefano Benigni and Annarita Patriarca of Forza Italia, who in February 2025 accused the Fratelli d’Italia group of presenting “the contents of certain hearings as already established and conclusive” during a press conference. Malan was among the organisers.
As for the “decisions taken by those with institutional responsibility” referred to by Lisei, during the pandemic these were taken by the government, the regions and the health authorities, who are accountable for them. It is the responsibility of scientists to explain the quality of the advice provided and the evidence on which it was based. The FNOMCeO explicitly distinguishes between the responsibility for collective decisions – which lies with politics – and the task of science to produce knowledge through the verification of evidence.
The President of the Senate, Ignazio La Russa, has already called for “mutual respect for the prerogatives of both the opposition and the majority”. Do La Russa and the President of the Chamber of Deputies, Lorenzo Fontana, intend to investigate who is drafting the Commission’s scientific questions and what qualifications they possess?