Viale Jonio ‘bombarded’ by bird droppings. An expert on starlings speaks out

Zoologist Bruno Cignini speaks to Il Foglio: “There is a tried-and-tested method, and specialist firms capable of putting it into practice. The local council should contact them and follow this approach; acting haphazardly by asking members of the public to make the distress call, on the other hand, only risks convincing the starlings that they are facing a bluff.”

19 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Viale Jonio ‘bombarded’ by bird droppings. An expert on starlings speaks out
“There is a well-established method, and specialist firms capable of putting it into practice. The local council should contact them and follow this approach; acting haphazardly by asking members of the public to sound the alarm, on the other hand, risks only convincing the starlings that they are facing a bluff,” zoologist Bruno Cignini tells Il Foglio. The starlings affair between Viale Jonio and Viale Pantelleria, in the capital’s 3rd municipal district, has become a serious matter.
For about a month now, hundreds of thousands of birds have chosen the neighbourhood’s trees as their roost, literally bombarding streets, cars and passers-by with droppings, filling the neighbourhood with an unbearable stench and forcing Ama to carry out more than one clean-up shift a day. The local council has taken action, even asking residents to play the distress call – the infamous sound intended to persuade the birds to fly away – from their balconies and terraces. “The first two companies called in by the council,” says Cignini, “did a poor job; now they’re trying this DIY solution, which doesn’t convince me at all.” The council, however, stands by the operation. “The contractors are still working, too, including with the use of visual deterrents. What we and the residents are doing is a supporting measure to increase the decibel level. It’s working,” says Matteo Zocchi, the councillor for the environment in the 3rd municipal district.
Cignini isn’t convinced. A lecturer in urban wildlife conservation and management at Tor Vergata, he has been studying starlings for at least 40 years: “I am the person who, in the late 1990s, devised the method right here in Rome for scaring them away using distress calls. At that time,” he explains, “the starlings decided to come and sleep in the city. They are commuter birds and very intelligent: they realised it was warmer and safer here. In the morning, at dawn, they set off, like proper commuters, towards the countryside to feed, and in the evening they return to their roosts in the city. They do all this together because they are a social species: every flock consists of at least hundreds of thousands of birds.”
Even the town hall is trying out the distress call. “The system,” explains the zoologist, “is based not on the hawk’s cry, as many believe, but on the sound of the starling itself. It is an alarm call that one or more individuals emit when there is imminent danger: upon hearing it, the starlings fly away, but to convince them that the danger is real, you have to get it right. It took me two years just to sample and fine-tune the sound.”
And here, according to Cignini, something has gone wrong – at least so far. “You can’t just do things haphazardly. You need to understand the animal’s biology, how the roost works and, above all, you have to be there at exactly the right time: if you get it wrong, it’s a real disaster.” Could you explain that further? “Starlings return to their roosts in groups. If we play the sound too early, we’ll scare off the first group, but they’ll come back, drawn back by the others who are returning. If, on the other hand, we play the sound too late, it will be night-time and the starlings will consider it too dangerous to move at that moment. The sound,” continues the professor, “must be played roughly halfway through the evening, for a quarter of an hour in total. The operation must be repeated for three days: only then will the entire flock be driven away. The first companies that worked in the 3rd municipal district went for a day and then returned a week later. That doesn’t work. And it is just as dangerous to leave a protocol that must be carried out so precisely to the goodwill of the public; if the birds think it’s a bluff, then for four weeks – the time it takes for them to forget what happened – it’s impossible to do anything else.”
But what if it does work? Isn’t there a risk that the starlings will simply move to a different neighbourhood? “Here,” he says, “comes the most interesting part. The companies have to track the starlings. Once they’ve moved, they might end up in a park – in which case they mustn’t be disturbed any further – or in other neighbourhoods. In the latter case, the operation has to be repeated. Slowly, like the Pied Piper, we manage to move them all to suitable locations. Although – as Cignini recalls – years ago we made a serious mistake: the birds had moved to Verano; it seemed like a suitable place to us, but we hadn’t considered that after a few days the graves and headstones would be covered in 10 centimetres of guano.”