Religion
GOVERNING THE CHURCH •
The Prevost Code. Understanding the Pope through his appointments
Past, present and potential appointments to understand how Leo XIV intends to govern the Church. The message is clear: unity. How to achieve it is more complicated. A map

Rome. It was clear from the very first words he spoke after his election, a year and a half ago, but Leo XIV wished to reiterate to journalists what is one of his priorities – and probably his main one: to restore unity within the Church. He cited the example of viri probati – married men of mature age to be ordained to make up for the shortage of priests: they were wanted in the Amazon, where it can be years before a priest passes through some remote community to administer Holy Communion. But they would also be wanted in Belgium, for other, far more worldly reasons. The Pope said no, explaining that this is merely one of several possible solutions and that, in any case, giving the green light to viri probati would only fuel controversy, strife and divisions within the Church. Better to avoid it. It is likely that the Pope’s forthcoming appointments, designed to shape the governance of the Church in his own image, will also be viewed through the prism of unity. So far, in fact, he has limited himself to a few minor adjustments, mostly due to age-related changes or to fill vacancies. There are two exceptions: the transfer to Łódź, in Poland, of Cardinal Konrad Krajewski, who is just over sixty, and that of Cardinal Mauro Gambetti to Chieti-Vasto. Otherwise, Leo XIV has proved wrong those who predicted a rapid turnover of curial officials well beyond the canonical age of seventy-five, which triggers retirement. There are quite a few of them.
Arthur Roche, aged 76 (Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments), Marcello Semeraro, approaching 79 (Causes of Saints), Kevin Farrell, aged 79 (Laity, Family and Life), Kurt Koch, aged 76 (Christian Unity), and Lazzaro You Heung-sik (Clergy), who turned 75 a few days ago. So far, the Pope has appointed a moderate Italian to head the Dicastery for Bishops (Monsignor Filippo Iannone), a reformist liturgist as archpriest of St Peter’s (Monsignor Vittorio Viola), a nun to the Dicastery for Integral Human Development (Sister Alessandra Smerilli), an Australian canonist to the Dicastery for Legislative Texts (Monsignor Anthony Randazzo), and a layperson to the Dicastery for Communication (Montse Alvarado). There is no ideological line running through these appointments, and this is the defining feature of the approach that Leo seems to be taking to governance. At times it seems confusing: the sociologist Luca Diotallevi, for example, remarked that it is difficult to understand how one could appoint a staunch and rigorous liturgist who applies the teachings of Vatican II – such as Monsignor Viola – to the role of archpriest of St Peter’s, whilst at the same time permitting (a year ago) the celebration of the Vetus Ordo Mass at the Altar of the Chair during the Ad Petri Sedem pilgrimage. Another textbook example is the appointment of the then CEO of EWTN – a conservative American network criticised by Pope Francis – as prefect of the Dicastery for Communication. There are two possible interpretations. The first is that of the ‘big tent’, an expression coined by the then Archbishop of Chicago, Cardinal Joseph Bernardin, former president of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops and for a long time the undisputed leader of the liberal wing of the Church in the United States. In Bernardin’s vision, the ‘big tent’ was intended to accommodate Catholics with different sensibilities – even diametrically opposed ones – regarding morality and political ideals. The aim was simple: to overcome polarisation and foster dialogue as much as possible, smoothing out the sharpest edges that prevented the convergence of positions which were initially distant and seemingly irreconcilable. Robert Prevost, who describes himself as a ‘gringo’, grew up in that environment, and it is no coincidence that, in a famous lecture given in Peru a few years ago, he cited Bernardin as one of his points of reference.
Every action and word of Leo XIV re-establishes that model in Rome; he enshrined it in his motto (in illo uno, unum… in him who is one, we are one), reiterated it on various occasions and, most recently, whilst on a flight. Put into practice, this means: embracing everyone, even those with views different from his own, in order to foster unity. A very Giovanpaolino idea, come to think of it. Pope Wojtyla, during his long reign, made room for the most diverse viewpoints, as exemplified by his choice of Secretary of State following the death of Jean Villot at the start of his pontificate. He did not choose someone who fully shared his international political vision, someone who would work day and night to bring down the Wall. Instead, he chose a perfect representative of Ostpolitik, Agostino Casaroli. And the fact that the two were not on the same wavelength was recounted by Joseph Ratzinger, in response to a question from his biographer, Peter Seewald: “We used to talk about it (with John Paul II, ed.). It was clear that Casaroli’s policy, however well-intentioned, had failed. The new approach pursued by John Paul II stemmed from his personal experience and his contact with those powers. Of course, at the time one could not hope that the regime would collapse soon, but it was evident that, rather than being conciliatory and accepting compromises, one had to oppose it forcefully. This was John Paul II’s fundamental vision, which I shared.” Cardinal Joseph Zen is reported to have written that “there are those who say that the Pope wanted to use Casaroli as a smokescreen so as not to alarm the Russians and thus quietly carry out his plan to liberate Poland and Europe from communist dictatorships”. And what of the appointment of Carlo Maria Martini to Milan, certainly not the archetype of a Wojtyła-style bishop? Yet John Paul II transcended ideological divisions, including theologians such as Ratzinger, Kasper and Lehmann in the College of Cardinals. A tradition and style that were only broken by Francis, in the second phase of his pontificate: whilst he initially followed the same line (at the first consistory, for example, he conferred the cardinal’s red hat on Gerhard Ludwig Müller), it subsequently proved difficult to find, amongst the large number of cardinals created, anyone who differed from Jorge Mario Bergoglio’s ecclesial and pastoral vision.
Leone has not appointed any new cardinals, so only time will tell whether there will be a return to the pragmatic custom of keeping everyone in, or whether the decision made at the time by his immediate predecessor will continue. On the flight, the Pope was asked many questions specifically about the forthcoming consistory: when will it take place? It is not on the agenda, explained Prevost, noting that there are still many electors – “I believe 116” (Paul VI set the maximum, non-binding, limit at 120) – whilst demonstrating, however, that he keeps a close tally… Leone’s first consistory will be a key moment, as it will reveal a great deal about how he intends to address the tension towards unity in the governance of the Church. The creation of cardinals, in fact, is an act proper to the Pope that is not subject to any rule: the Pontiff may choose anyone; there are no cardinal sees by divine right; there are no constraints, advice or suggestions.
But there is a second interpretation, one that is far more pragmatic and typical of a Pope who is a mathematician accustomed to reasoning logically. Expertise. The very appointment of Montse Alvarado to the Communications Department demonstrates this. The fact that she was the head of the largest American Catholic network – and thus possessed management and practical experience – outweighed the fact that this network is considered conservative and had previously drawn criticism from Bergoglio: “There is a major Catholic television channel that has no qualms about constantly speaking ill of the Pope” and this is “the work of the devil”. In the Pope’s view, the then CEO was doing a good job, the results were tangible, and so the appointment was made. It has been pointed out on several occasions that Leo XIV promoted various canonists – that is, men of law, rigorous in the application of rules and regulations: a clear idea of what needs to be done, therefore.
In May, the election of the new president of the CEI will take place. The term of office of Cardinal Matteo Zuppi, elected in 2022, is coming to an end. Speaking in Bologna a few days ago, he said he could not comment on the matter: “I cannot answer that question today. I will respond in May.” Five years ago, during a general assembly, Pope Francis made it clear to the bishops that he would prefer the election of a cardinal, preferably under the age of 70, so that he could complete a full term as the incumbent ordinary. This time, it remains to be seen how Leone will proceed: will he allow freedom of vote, even refraining from suggesting any particular candidate? It is impossible to know at present, and entirely pointless to venture into predictions which – as things stand – would be little more reliable than the Delphic oracles.
More on these topics
Friulsardo, è nato nel 1986. Laureato in politica internazionale e diplomazia a Padova con tesi su turchi e americani, è stato arbitro di calcio. Al Foglio dal 2011, si occupa di Chiesa, Papi, religioni e libri. Scrittore prediletto: Joseph Roth (ma va bene qualunque cosa relativa alla finis Austriae). È caporedattore dal 2020.
