The ‘Gringo’ Pope: “When I speak, I tell it like it is”

No to the ‘viri probati’; no easing of restrictions on the traditional Mass for the time being. “One of my priorities is, first and foremost, to promote unity and communion amongst us as members of the Church.”

18 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of The ‘Gringo’ Pope: “When I speak, I tell it like it is”
Rome. “I believe that an important part of my ministry in the Church is to heal and unite people,” said the Pope on board the plane taking him back to Rome after his trip to South America, which ended with crowds in Lima waving him off and singing for him. Leo XIV was responding to a question about viri probati – married men of mature age – as a potential solution to the shortage of priests in certain parts of the world. This was discussed at length at the 2019 Synod on the Amazon, but Pope Francis subsequently decided against it: no viri probati. Leone said: “That is one of the proposed solutions. It is not the only one, and in some parts of the Church it may cause divisions, because this idea is not accepted by everyone. As I have made clear on several occasions during this short year and a half, or thereabouts, since I became Pope, one of my priorities is to promote, first and foremost, unity and communion amongst us as members of the Church. To take forward an idea that the Holy Spirit may continue to suggest – and which He may also suggest to others besides myself – we must all listen. The Pope does not change the Church’s doctrine. The bishops must listen. It may be that in the future some things will change.” “First of all, let us come together. Let us reflect on what we believe the priorities should be. Then we will see how to move forward. I am well aware that many people disagree with this approach. That is fine. I am here, and this is what I offer as part of my ministry. I believe that is enough for now, because the issue of married men in the clergy is complex. As we know, there are also those who put forward other proposals. But all these things will take time, and we shall proceed as the Lord guides us.” It remains to be seen how Monsignor Johan Bonny, the Bishop of Antwerp, will react. He has already made it clear to everyone (both at home and in Rome) that he intends to proceed with the ordination of viri probati, warning that any refusal by the Pope would be a great disappointment to him. It seems he is in for one. The Pope speaks plainly and has confirmed this himself: “In many ways I am a gringo, a North American. There was an article in one of the newspapers before the Conclave which said that ‘the least American of Americans’ is Prevost. I believe, amongst other things, that when I say things, I do so frankly and directly; I tell it like it is. The issue of my health – the fact of talking about it or even saying, ‘Well, I’m getting over this’ – would not be typical in many countries and many cultures. In the United States, it is a little more common. I do not want to raise any further questions here, but my deep faith in democracy and democratic participation is also part of being American.”
Much has been written about his first speech in Buenos Aires, which was interpreted by most of the media as an attack on the Argentine president. The Pope said: “I had already met President Milei in Rome, when he came to the Vatican. Politically speaking, he and Francis certainly represented very different viewpoints. Yet, apparently, they seemed to get on well. I would emphasise that the message I wish to convey, the message I wish to bring, is not political; and although in some countries there are people who try to push me to the right or to the left – whether they criticise me or not – I speak of the ‘Magnifica humanitas’, and this is what I discussed with President Milei. Yes, we spoke about economic issues, some of the difficulties the country is still facing since he took office. But above all, there was a sort of mutual understanding in recognising the value of life, the value of the human being at every stage, as we must seek to collaborate on this front.” There was also a question about a possible relaxation of Traditionis custodes, the motu proprio that restricted the celebration of the vetus ordo Mass: “Not for the time being,” said Leo XIV. “Traditionis custodes was a decision by Pope Francis and we will continue to follow it. Traditionis custodes includes the possibility of a dispensation or of permitting the celebration of Mass according to the vetus ordo. And so, once again, for the unity of the Church, the overwhelming majority of Catholics worldwide celebrate the rite of Vatican II, that of Paul VI, and we will continue to do so. There is a way forward for those who wish to apply for a dispensation.”