Politics
Strikes take their toll •
Over-reliance on general strikes weakens the trade union’s most important weapon
How the trade unions are undermining the general strike. Ever-widening platforms, vague objectives and competition between unions are turning this show of strength into a hollow ritual. Proclamations are multiplying, but the ability to influence decisions and achieve concrete results is waning. Even the CGIL risks devaluing a tool that should preserve

(Photo: Ansa)
The trade union’s ‘doomsday’ weapon – the general strike – has ceased to strike fear into people’s hearts. Long gone are the days when even the mere mention of such a strike would have a visible and measurable impact on economic or political stakeholders. The general strike – the one that calls everyone to action, which is supposed to bring the country to a standstill – has become a blunt weapon, a ritual that is repeated year after year. It is more a demonstration of its continued existence than a sign of strength or broad support amongst workers and across the country.
There is one question the trade union should ask itself before calling a general strike: not what message we intend to send, not what political stance we wish to reaffirm, not how many press releases we will manage to produce, but what concrete result do we expect to achieve? What result. Because a strike is not a demonstration like any other. It is one of the most important tools at the workers’ movement’s disposal, but it is also a tool that demands a sacrifice from those who use it: a day’s pay, the forgoing of part of one’s income, which is often already insufficient. This was often emphasised by the leaders who made the CGIL great, as well as those of the CISL and UIL, who, when faced with the decision to call a strike, would carefully weigh up the pros and cons. The decision was never taken lightly.
It is precisely for this reason that strikes – and general strikes in particular – should be used sparingly, thoughtfully and responsibly. Over the last six years, the CGIL, either on its own, alongside the UIL, or in conjunction with other organisations, has organised eight general strikes and several national protests. To these must be added countless announcements from other trade union organisations, including smaller unions and grassroots trade union movements. The phenomenon therefore does not concern the CGIL alone. However, it is precisely the decision by Italy’s largest trade union confederation to resort to this measure with increasing frequency that makes the issue particularly significant.
The point is not to deny that the causes of discontent have increased. Wages have lost purchasing power; precarious employment, although on the decline, continues to affect the lives of millions of people; the public health service is in difficulty; industrial policies are struggling; and the social security system is riddled with deep-seated contradictions. And, of course, there is war, rearmament, energy tensions, governments’ economic policy choices, the situation facing young people, women’s issues and LGBTQIAP+ concerns.
Calling for action on truly important issues is right, but lumping everything together on a single platform, turning the general strike into a sort of universal catch-all for all the issues in public debate, is problematic.
The workers’ ‘doomsday’ weapon has become a blunt instrument: the more such proclamations multiply, the less they manage to instil fear or influence decisions. From being an exceptional means of exerting pressure, it has now become merely a declaration that they are still alive.
Contemporary platforms for social struggle may encompass, side by side, wages, pensions, taxation, tariffs, healthcare, schools, universities, housing, industrial policy, the environment, peace, international politics, legal and constitutional frameworks, and criticism of the governments of other states. These are important issues, often of the utmost urgency, but they cannot be reduced to a single dispute, least of all when promoted by trade unions which, institutionally, ought to be concerned – if not primarily, then at least to a large extent – with the protection of workers, economic and social policies, and the defence of the democratic order, as has so often been the case in the past.
The result is a vague, protest-driven movement in which it becomes difficult to identify a priority, a specific counterpart, a verifiable objective and, above all, a demand on which to exert effective pressure. At times, strikes are even called against a Budget Bill before its content has been finalised and the details made public. A general strike should focus the workforce’s efforts on an issue of general interest, rather than turning into a permanent referendum on the entire political direction of the government in power. The frequency of such announcements has become such that even the distinction between a general strike, a multi-sector strike and a sector-specific mobilisation is tending to disappear, not only in public discourse but also in the public consciousness.
According to the report by the Guarantee Commission, the number of general strike calls has doubled, rising from 17 in 2024 to 33 in 2025. The Commission itself attributed the increase almost entirely to the initiatives of smaller trade unions and grassroots trade unionism. This figure does not mean that there were 27 national days on which the country came to a standstill: it means that various calls for strikes, often overlapping, resulted in a much smaller number of actual days of mobilisation. This is the effect of the political and trade union rivalry that has emerged on the left. Strikes are called so as not to leave others with a monopoly on protest over issues that mobilise one’s own base of workers and citizens. In 2026, the situation remained unchanged. Between March and November, there were eight calls for general or multi-sector strikes, not all of the same nature or scale. This proliferation ultimately strips of meaning a form of industrial action that should signify something exceptional, devaluing a mobilisation that should involve the world of work and exert real pressure on institutions and negotiating partners.
When every initiative is labelled ‘general’, the term gradually loses its significance. And when the calendar is littered with general strikes, the ability of each one to capture the public’s attention and influence decisions risks diminishing. It is not enough to call a strike for the country to come to a standstill. Nor is it enough for a demonstration to fill a square for the demands of those taking part to be heard. Comparisons with the past are inevitable. Not because strikes in the past were detached from politics or because their platforms were always straightforward. But because, during the most significant periods of the trade union movement, the general strike was generally linked to particularly serious developments, to recognisable conflicts or to objectives capable of translating into concrete achievements.
The issue is not so much grassroots trade unionism, but rather that in recent years even the CGIL has come to embrace this approach
This was the situation in July 1960, following the killings and clashes with the police in several cities, including Reggio Emilia, when the CGIL called a national general strike against the Tambroni government, at the height of the dispute over political overtures towards the MSI. That ‘democratic uprising’ against the repression of a government backed by monarchists and fascists, and the toll of deaths in the streets, led to the government’s resignation and the dawn of a new era in the country.
In March 1968, the trade unions brought Italy to a standstill over pensions. The dispute continued with further industrial action and contributed to the 1969 pension reform, which introduced improvements to pension entitlements and the state pension. In 1969, workers’ struggles and the general strike over housing on 19 November formed part of a period of conflict that helped to bring about the abolition of wage barriers, which was completed in 1972.
During the ‘hot autumn’, the struggles of the metalworkers led to decisive victories: pay rises, a reduction in working hours to 40 hours per week, the right to assemble, and greater power for workers in the workplace. Many of those achievements were subsequently enshrined in the 1970 Workers’ Statute. Furthermore, there were the major strikes in defence of democracy, such as those following the numerous massacres and the murders of public servants. There were also the demonstrations against terrorism, those calling for the development of Southern Italy and for the unity of the country.
In more recent years, the mobilisation by the CGIL, CISL and UIL trade unions in 1994 against the attempted pension reform sought by the first Berlusconi government helped to thwart the pension reform and formed part of the political crisis that led to the government’s downfall.
Even when the results of the protests might have seemed disappointing, the reasons for calling them were always clear and well-founded. One could debate the strategy and outcome of the struggles, but it was always made explicit which measure was being opposed and what alternative policy was being proposed. These are different events, which took place in vastly different historical contexts. Yet they share one common element: the mobilisation was a response to a real conflict and had recognisable objectives. The strike was not an exercise in gaining visibility, but a tool for shifting the balance of power and achieving results.
Michele De Palma, who has recently joined the CGIL’s confederal secretariat after serving as secretary of the metalworkers’ union and is widely tipped as the future successor to Maurizio Landini, sets out an argument in a recent interview that clarifies the new meaning the trade union based on Corso d’Italia attributes to the strike. The CGIL, he argues, has embarked on a strenuous struggle to uphold democracy, a struggle in which conflict is a structural element. At present, he continues, the institutional route is blocked, as can be seen from what happened with the budget bill presented to Parliament before the meeting with the trade unions. For De Palma, the strike is the response to this alleged expropriation of bargaining power and should no longer be regarded as a one-off decisive action, but rather as a show of strength and the start of a dispute destined to continue. The future trade union leader also outlines a number of objectives: to increase wages, make the tax system more progressive, defend healthcare and education, counter the loss of industrial sovereignty and safeguard the welfare state, achieve peace and combat the war economy.
Emanuele De Luca, coordinator of CLAP (Chambers of Self-Employed and Precarious Workers), a grassroots organisation founded in Rome in 2013, acknowledges in a recent article that recent years have seen a glut of strike dates, which have often failed to have any real impact on actual work stoppages or on the political debate. He argues that these calls for action have served mainly to consolidate vested interests and to stake out positions. Strikes, on the other hand, should become a cornerstone of social mobilisation, capable of bringing together permanent and precarious workers, students, movements in support of Palestine, protests against the cost of living, demands for investment in education and healthcare, and opposition to rearmament.
Both highlight a real problem: the fragmentation of work, the growing number of workers in precarious and intermittent employment, and the difficulty of organising people who no longer identify with traditional forms of representation. And it is worth remembering that social issues do not exist in isolation: war, energy, inflation, wages and welfare can be linked by concrete economic and political connections. In both approaches, the convergence of objectives is highlighted as indispensable, but it also risks becoming the criterion used to justify the platform’s continuous expansion. If the strike is to give a voice to all forms of mobilisation, link every grievance and represent every social group, what then becomes the main issue at stake? What is the demand against which the strike’s success is measured? Who must be persuaded to change their decision, and through what means of pressure?
De Luca criticises the ritualistic proclamations of the past, but proposes that strikes should serve to amplify the mobilisation of individual social groups. This is a politically understandable perspective, but it does not resolve the issue of the effectiveness of industrial action. A protest movement may be diverse, but for a dispute to yield results, it requires a clearly defined demand, a negotiating partner and a negotiation process.
De Palma states that the objectives must be clear and concrete: wages, taxation, healthcare, education. But immediately afterwards, he places the strike within a much broader context, which encompasses the crisis of democracy, war, the European model of development, industrial sovereignty, the ecological transition, security and the sustainability of the welfare state. These are all relevant issues, but their importance alone is not enough to automatically make them a unified platform for industrial action.
De Palma and De Luca share a criticism of the old trade union rituals, but end up entrusting the strike with a truly vast mission: to bring together different conflicts, build a social opposition, foster collective consciousness and usher in a new political phase. A vast programme, as de Gaulle would say.
People used to go on strike for specific causes. In 1960 against Tambroni, in ’68 over pensions, then the ‘Hot Autumn’
What this trade union model proposes is a possible role for a movement, a political force, a coalition or a period of mobilisation. However, it cannot replace the specific role of a strike: to stop work in order to exert pressure on an opposing party and achieve a result.
Diversity is not the problem. The problem arises when diversity becomes indistinct and convergence takes precedence over priorities. It is possible to build a broad coalition without expecting a single day of strike action to represent everything. Indeed, precisely in order to bring together different groups, it is necessary to distinguish between the various disputes, define common objectives and allow each mobilisation to retain its autonomy.
Today, the proliferation of general strikes risks producing a paradoxical effect: the more a mobilisation is announced, the less recognisable the significance of the proclamation becomes. For smaller unions and grassroots trade unionism, a strike can also become a way of asserting their presence, gaining visibility, signalling a political stance and distinguishing themselves from the larger organisations. This is an understandable dynamic in terms of trade union competition, but not necessarily effective in terms of representing workers.
The fact that Italy’s largest trade union confederation is also associated with this line of thinking is problematic. When the CGIL aligns itself with organisations that have very different mobilisation capacities and platforms, it risks contributing to the devaluation of the very instrument it should instead be preserving.
This is not to argue that a strike is legitimate only if it involves the majority of workers or if it achieves an immediate result. Trade union freedom also encompasses the possibility of calling for minority or unsuccessful industrial action. But a major trade union confederation has a different responsibility: it should help to ensure that a general strike is a moment of extraordinary concentration of collective strength, not just another item on the political and trade union calendar.
Otherwise, the call for a strike ends up looking more and more like a declaration of existence. It serves to announce that one is present, that one is opposed, that one is ready to take action. But it is not equally clear what is being sought, from whom, or by what means.
There is one aspect that should never be forgotten. Behind every strike there are workers who are giving up part of their wages. People on low wages, with precarious contracts, families to support and limited financial means. For them, taking part is not a gesture made for nothing, nor is it a mere declaration of solidarity. Respect for those on strike should compel those calling for action to take on an even greater sense of responsibility. Before calling on people to abstain from work, a trade union should ask itself whether the conditions exist to achieve a result, whether the platform is sufficiently clear, whether the opposing party has been identified, whether the mobilisation has a realistic chance of making an impact, and whether the sacrifice demanded of workers is proportionate to the objective.
Not every conflict can be resolved by a strike. Not every protest need necessarily lead to an immediate victory. But a general strike should at least be conceived as part of a strategy, with objectives, key stakeholders and a clear course of action to exert pressure.
We don’t need bans. We need choices. We need proposals – preferably credible ones. Fewer days of action, concrete platforms, a negotiating partner, a measurable objective. The general strike must once again become a tool capable of channelling the conflict and producing results.
Otherwise, it remains a political battle that benefits only those who champion it. But it contributes little or nothing to the work itself. Because when everything becomes a reason to go on strike, there is a risk that there will no longer be a cause capable of truly mobilising people.