Forza Italia opens the debate on egg freezing

Cattaneo: “Ecco l’emendamento sul congelamento degli ovuli”. Ma cosa ne penserà FdI? 

21 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Forza Italia opens the debate on egg freezing
Rome. Hidden within the jungle of amendments lie landmines. Some are truly invisible, much like the female gametes that Forza Italia proposes to cryopreserve. The budget bill raises the issue of the falling birth rate: Italy is ageing, and so Antonio Tajani’s party, through a proposal by MP Alessandro Cattaneo, is responding to the demographic winter by freezing eggs. The question arises: what will Giorgia Meloni’s party make of this? And what will her undersecretary, Alfredo Mantovano, have to say? “I am a Catholic too,” Cattaneo, who tabled the amendment, tells Il Foglio. 
“I am religious and I see no incompatibility whatsoever between my article and Catholic morality.” We’ll come back to that. “Oocyte cryopreservation,” explains Alessandro Cattaneo, “is an issue that has often sparked heated public debate: this happened, for example, when Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez declared that she had done so.” Yes. And do you think it will spark debate again? “I welcome any discussion on the matter. I’m from Pavia, where I served as mayor and where I met specialists, such as Rossella Nappi, who deal with these issues. Talking about it, regardless of the content of my amendment, is a way of raising awareness amongst young women”. Certainly. And yet, back in August, Fratelli d’Italia rejected a proposal from the Five Star Movement that would have extended free treatment to women in their thirties. “No, that’s not it. My idea is different. Today, the National Health Service already provides it for women with cancer. I believe, as I’ve written, that it should be extended free of charge to anyone suffering from conditions that could compromise fertility. Endometriosis, pre-menopause and so on.” Not for everyone, then. “No. But I think everyone should be aware of it, should know about it. I think the debate – both cultural and scientific – is essential even for young women who, at thirty, do not want to get pregnant but who might change their minds over the years and regret not having chosen this option.” Not an indiscriminate extension, then, but a gradual one. “It’s a matter of justice.” Have you discussed this within the coalition? “No. We haven’t discussed it yet.” You won’t stumble again, after the e-books… “Many women in Forza Italia have spoken out, but I see no reason why our allies should oppose it.” You don’t see any, but it wouldn’t be the first time. Especially on so-called ethical issues: I’m thinking solely of end-of-life care. “Sensitivities differ, of course. But in this case there would be clinical grounds behind it. What is the reason for depriving women – whether pre-menopausal or suffering from endometriosis – of this opportunity?” Let’s think about it: if the cryopreserved gamete were to be used, for example, in in vitro fertilisation, not everyone would be keen on introducing the gamete into the procedure. “The amendment aims to foster a mature and fair discussion so that the public health system can provide a response.” Yes. Although the women in Fratelli d’Italia, when discussing birth rates, tend to take a different line. “They say we need to put women in a position to have children, and that’s true. I myself am not entirely convinced that free access should be extended to everyone in the future. But it is good that the debate continues, even if it is a step-by-step process.” Is it feasible in terms of funding? “At present, the resources allocated to Parliament are limited. This measure would cost two million euros over three years. You ask me if it is feasible and I say yes. If we want it, it is.” We do indeed need to want it. “We need to want it. And I think it would send a positive signal.”