Politics
distinctions and divisions •
De Gennaro and the state funeral. Fini: “A country where even funerals turn into rivalry and cheering”
The former Speaker of the Chamber of Deputies remembers De Gennaro and asks: “Will we be able to avoid dividing ourselves? I fear we will not. His death will be yet another small yet significant mystery.” Meanwhile, the political battle has already begun, with hatred and accusations levelled in absentia against the former Chief of Police

Even now that he is dead, they accuse him in absentia, and to anyone who writes about Gianni De Gennaro – who took his own life at his country home – they wish the same fate: a gunshot. Sleep. On social media, they call him ‘De Gennaro the butcher’, and photographs are dug up from the G8 summit in Genoa – the cracked skulls, the shattered bones at the Diaz school – when De Gennaro was head of the police. Gianfranco Fini, former Speaker of the Chamber of Deputies and founder of AN—who, like the whole of the Republic, knew De Gennaro—says: “I reflect and wonder how we will manage to divide ourselves. And we will divide ourselves.” I ask Fini whether De Gennaro will be remembered as ‘the divisive De Gennaro’, and Fini wonders: ‘Who did he divide, and from whom? De Gennaro’s death will be another great little mystery. It is a painful and tragic loss, and I can already foresee that there will be those calling for a state funeral and those opposed to it. As for me personally, I shall not be attending’.
Some distinguish between solemn funerals and state funerals, whilst others believe it is the De Gennaro family who wish for a private ceremony. His brother Andrea, commander of the Guardia di Finanza, received a phone call from Sergio Mattarella, who also featured in the Caltanissetta wiretaps. When news of the death broke, the minutes were counted. Just as when one reads obituaries, the press release was scrutinised. The first statement from the government came from Mantovano, followed by Salvini, Meloni, Giorgetti and Crosetto. Andrea Orlando, the former Minister of Justice and a son of the party – the Italian Communist Party (PCI) – observes with the straightforwardness of a staunch communist: “De Gennaro was a man of the state who carried the contradictions of the state with him.”
It is said that Giorgio Napolitano, whenever there was a change of government and the section headed by De Gennaro came up, would reply: ‘You can change everyone, except De Gennaro’. He had more friends on the left. His friends knew one another. One was Luciano Violante, who mourns him in Il Foglio: ‘They have torn him to pieces’. The other was Marco Minniti, a former Minister of the Interior from the left. They are leading figures from a bygone era. They are growing older, surviving illness, pain and loss, and view this Caltanissetta investigation as something dangerous. On the left, they believe it is “an attempt to rewrite the anti-Mafia narrative in the style of the Italian Social Movement” and that it is also being used to settle scores on the right. Some link De Gennaro’s death to other suicides, seeing them as part of a single thread: Calvi, Gardini… Gianfranco Fini, who keeps his distance, says that, based on how he ‘knew him, I cannot object to De Gennaro deserving a state funeral. And yet I wonder: will we be able to avoid dividing ourselves? I fear we will not’. We shall have no truth, and even this will serve to incite those who seek it; it will help them to hunt down brothers and children, loved ones – those ties which, in Italy, are merely collateral damage.
More on these topics
Carmelo Caruso, giornalista a Palermo, Milano, Roma. Ha iniziato a La Repubblica. Oggi lavora al Foglio


