Politics
The case •
Before the shot rang out in the darkness, there was the commotion and the media and judicial witch-hunt. The scene in which De Gennaro’s suicide unfolded
From the search on 12 November to the flimsy allegations made by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office, which were promptly picked up by certain sections of the press. Then came the wiretaps and the insinuations, the suspicions deliberately circulated. The role of the media in the tragic death of the former Chief of Police

The gunshot in the darkness and, before that, the sound: the gunshot with which, on 21 November, the former prefect and former head of the police and secret services, Gianni De Gennaro – a friend and colleague of Giovanni Falcone during the ‘Maxi-trial’ against the Cosa Nostra – took his own life at his country home, in Tuscany; and the crescendoing, deafening and all-encompassing clamour of the media and judicial hype surrounding the investigation by the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office, led by Public Prosecutor Salvatore De Luca.
Allegation: obstruction of the investigation into the Via D’Amelio massacre, with De Gennaro, aged 78, placed on the list of suspects in mid-November following a dawn raid, amidst a flurry of headlines, insinuations and the public airing of wiretaps, with the spotlight fixed on the phrase that stood out in bold as proof (in the media, if not in court) of guilt, outside the courtroom and in the public square of pre-trial condemnation: that ‘I destroyed everything’ – which, in the view of investigating magistrate Giulia Zappalà, had not seemed sufficient, along with other alleged evidence, to order the precautionary measure, namely house arrest for the suspect.
Reasoning: the evidence gathered did not prove that the actions in question were intended to obstruct the investigations into the massacre in which Paolo Borsellino died and the disappearance of his red diary (however, the investigating judge left the door open for the case to proceed: the investigation, she wrote, had the ‘merit’ of opening up ‘new perspectives’ on the period of Mafia massacres). But the clamour, the one reverberating around De Gennaro, had by then already become a din and a drumbeat, all the more so after the Caltanissetta Public Prosecutor’s Office had decided to appeal for a review, renewing the request for his arrest: if ‘left at liberty’, so argued the Caltanissetta prosecutors, De Gennaro might commit the offences of which he was accused once again. Vague offences, yet revived amidst a whirlwind of half-truths, grand but incomplete statements (intercepted) and hypothetical truths. At dawn on 12 November, the aforementioned search of De Gennaro’s premises and those of some of his close associates marked what those close to the former prefect describe as the beginning of the end and the descent into the dark, inner and unfathomable vortex that led to today’s tragedy: the former prefect cutting all ties with everyone, taking refuge in the countryside, not answering his phone; his family, alarmed, calling the police.
Finally, regarding the news of the suicide, Salvatore Borsellino, Paolo’s brother, explains and comments as follows: “He took his own life because the accusations levelled against him were undoubtedly unfounded. Therefore, this constitutes incitement to suicide. These are shocking reports. Furthermore, when discussing suicides of this kind, we must establish whether it was indeed a suicide or something else. Only the judiciary will be able to determine that.”
“Shocked by the defamatory allegations,” says De Gennaro’s lawyer, Francesco Bertorotta, recounting his latest telephone conversation with the former Chief of Police, aimed at finalising the written submission ahead of 1 December, the day on which the prosecution and defence were due to face off once more at the review hearing, had it not been for the death which, by removing the suspect from the scene, puts a media-judicial approach in the dock even before any individual or individuals, and ahead of any ascertainment of the facts and culpability. And that is not all: whilst the wiretaps were being reported one after another in the pages of the daily newspapers, from La Repubblica to Il Fatto and on to La Stampa and Domani, a parallel media frenzy began over De Gennaro’s alleged past (albeit political) manoeuvres surrounding the previous appointment of his brother Andrea, the current commander-in-chief of the Guardia di Finanza (a post due to expire on 31 December and, given the tensions linked to the Caltanissetta inquiry, one that is unlikely to be extended).
And so began the next round of rumour-mongering – as vociferous as ever – concerning the former Chief of Police’s ‘alleged powerful friends’. This was compounded by a heavy barrage of mudslinging, both before and after the Caltanissetta inquiry: a jumble of belated statements and revelations regarding the March 1994 leak – in the midst of the election campaign – concerning Silvio Berlusconi, Marcello Dell’Utri and Cosa Nostra, published by La Repubblica and authored by Giuseppe D’Avanzo and Attilio Bolzoni, based on the revelations of the turncoat Salvatore Cancemi. One of the two key figures behind that scoop, Bolzoni, published an account in Il Domani on 20 November last year, looking back on those days more than thirty years on, focusing on the source – the man who had enabled him and ‘Peppe’ (D’Avanzo) to obtain Cancemi’s transcripts (the name, Bolzoni says, had already been revealed by Ilda Boccassini: it was he, De Gennaro, who ‘after that “tip-off” would rise through all the echelons of power’). De Gennaro had spoken about this before the judges in Florence in 2024, denying the allegations outright: “I don’t know why what you’re reminding me of was said, but it is certain that I did not have Salvatore Cancemi’s minutes, nor did I hand them over to D’Avanzo. I risked my life to fight the Cosa Nostra; I don’t see why I should have helped Riina and his associates.” This took place two years ago in a courtroom. But the frenzied stream of revelations and wiretaps that became public in 2026 began to race back and forth through time. Then came the bugging of the office and the accusations from Caltanissetta. And we return to that dawn of the search, on 12 November, and the onset of even greater pressure to admit guilt. The rest is darkness, a darkness broken by a gunshot.
More on these topics
Marianna Rizzini è nata e cresciuta a Roma, tra il liceo Visconti e l'Università La Sapienza, assorbendo forse i tic di entrambi gli ambienti, ma più del Visconti che della Sapienza. Per fortuna l'hanno spedita per tempo a Milano, anche se poi è tornata indietro. Lavora al Foglio dai primi anni del Millennio e scrive per lo più ritratti di personaggi politici o articoli su sinistre sinistrate, Cinque Stelle e populisti del web, ma può capitare la paginata che non ti aspetti (strani individui, perfetti sconosciuti, storie improbabili, robot, film, cartoni animati). E' nata in una famiglia pazza, ma con il senno di poi neanche tanto. Vive a Trastevere, è mamma di Tea, esce volentieri, non è un asso dei fornelli.
