Politics
Marina’s fears •
Meloni’s ‘backpack’: she wins the e-book challenge. Tajani’s ‘double’
Forza Italia votes against the amendment on digital textbooks, but the bill passes in the Senate thanks to Calenda’s votes and the absence of PD members. The clash with Meloni puts Tajani in a difficult position, whilst Marina Berlusconi fears the consequences of the measure for the publishing market. Boccia (PD) praises Stefania Craxi and does not rule out future dialogue with Forza Italia.

(Photo: Ansa)
Those wishing Tajani ill will say today: as far as Marina Berlusconi is concerned, he is a loser, and as far as Meloni is concerned, he remains Marina’s deputy. In the Senate, Forza Italia votes against the amendment on e-books, but the measure is passed thanks to Calenda’s votes and the PD’s abstentions (86 to 74). A vote of confidence will be put to the Chamber of Deputies. Francesco Boccia is already praising this partisan Forza Italia: “Stefania Craxi’s vote is important; it is a political statement”. Meloni, in Berlin with the Volenterosi, phones Tajani. Fazzolari appears in the Chamber. Within FdI, the line is clear: “We won’t pay protection money to Mondadori”. Meloni returns to Rome, saying: “This is proof that I answer only to the Italian people”. For FdI, there is “malice” (or perhaps a ploy) on the part of Tajani, who had “initially agreed”.
If, at the age of 91, people are still writing about Gianni Letta, it is because with Letta, matches could be lost, but not one’s dignity. Forza Italia loses at home and loses badly. On Wednesday evening, Tajani convenes a meeting with the senators and urges them to press ahead, vote against the motion, and ‘send a signal’. For FdI, this is ‘enormous pressure’ from Marina Berlusconi. In Segrate, these claims are denied. Within FI, it is pointed out that at the publishers’ assembly, Mondadori even abstained on the provision regarding these digital books – to be charged at 50 per cent – aimed at tackling the high cost of books and embracing modernity. Marina makes no comment. Reports of phone calls between Marina and Meloni are denied. The Berlusconi family refers to the concerns raised by the publishers’ association, merely repeating that the measure is unconvincing. There is more.
It is a provision that, for Mondadori, risks undermining copyright. Schools today, but what about tomorrow? The real fear concerns the entry of foreign publishers into the book market. FdI is targeting Tajani. The first attempt to introduce the provision was made in the budget bill, but the chairman of the Chamber of Deputies’ Budget Committee, Giuseppe Mangialavori of FI, struck it out. It is a sign. Meloni wants this provision, which a note from FdI’s research department describes as “a historic battle for the student right, designed to combat the heavy financial burden of expensive textbooks and to protect our families”. Meloni wants it to tell the students protesting in the streets: with us, textbooks cost less. And she also wants it because “it is a liberal provision”.
Initially, when the amendment was tacked onto the Budget Bill, Valditara was opposed. He, too, believed that printed books are better for learning than e-books. The minister was contacted by Salvini and Meloni, and his reservations were dispelled. That left Forza Italia. Meloni discussed the matter with Tajani. This has been confirmed. Tajani did not object. Within Forza Italia, some speculate that Tajani agreed in order to snub Stefania Craxi, leaving her with the sting of her first defeat and demonstrating to Marina that it is wiser to negotiate with Meloni—and that he knows how to do so better than anyone else. There is some truth to this notion of negotiation: within FdI, sources explain that it was possible to discuss how much to pay for copyright in digital format. In short, mediating, reaching an agreement: what more do you need?
There could have been a debate about raising the figure from fifty to sixty per cent. That did not happen. First came Tajani’s green light, followed by his opposition. That is why Arianna Meloni intervened. Forza Italia was informed that this was a decisive vote. The final seal on the matter is the arrival of Fazzolari, who takes his seat in the Chamber. FI has been under close scrutiny for weeks, ever since it rejected the reinstatement of anti-vaccine doctors, on the advice of the Medical Association. Even in that case, FdI complains, FI had initially given its approval and then changed its mind. That’s not on. It’s not done. As for Meloni, Calenda is considered more reliable, even though, as Minister Ciriani says, “I don’t think he’ll ultimately join the right”. Meloni does not like Craxi’s constant flirting with the PD, so much so that Francesco Boccia told Il Foglio: “When Craxi stands up and says in the Chamber that the government has cut funding for schools, when he votes against his own government, it is clear that he is taking a political stance.” Take note of these words from Boccia.
When asked about a hypothetical future alliance with FI after the vote: “Our task is to strengthen our coalition. With Forza Italia afterwards? We’ll see. The coalition comes first.” Boccia praises Craxi, not Tajani. Craxi. In the FdI statement, FI’s vote against the motion is downplayed as mere “disappointment”. It is a carefully worded statement. The annoyance towards the Berlusconi family is expressed in this sentence: “Forza Italia’s opposition comes as no surprise: it is in its political nature to be particularly attentive to the demands and concerns of the business world”. Another sector is toying with the idea of peace. Within the government, despite everything, they believe it is within reach. In Berlin, Meloni appeals to China to put pressure on Russia. Regarding the three-way summit between Trump, Putin and Xi in Shenzhen, she laments Ukraine’s absence. If peace is achieved, the election timetable will change – and perhaps Tajani’s plans too. The latest idea is to wait until April, to see if a windfall can be received from Europe to spend and to amend the budget, and thus to spend, donate (as well as write off debts). And this, too, is a book. A book of dreams.
More on these topics
Carmelo Caruso, giornalista a Palermo, Milano, Roma. Ha iniziato a La Repubblica. Oggi lavora al Foglio
