The Renzi-Salvini exchange in the Senate: “The minister is as late as the trains; he doesn’t get a single thing right.”

During Question Time at Palazzo Madama, the leader of Italia Viva attacked the Deputy Prime Minister by listing the issues he has been dealing with in recent weeks. The Transport Minister highlighted the rise in passenger numbers, defended the continuity of the service on the eve of the strike and retorted by taking a dig at the senator over his links with Saudi Arabia.

19 NOV 26
Translated by AI
(photo: Ansa)

(photo: Ansa)

One launches an attack, the other reels off figures. This afternoon in the Senate chamber, a heated exchange took place between Italia Viva leader Matteo Renzi and Transport Minister Matteo Salvini. The occasion was a parliamentary question on the issue of train delays, tabled by Italia Viva senators. 
The first piece began with a series of ironic observations on the minister and deputy prime minister’s communications strategy, listing the things Salvini was supposed to have said that week, without, however, achieving any results: “You, Minister, have been preoccupied with something entirely different this week. I have made a list myself and I am almost tempted to sympathise with you. You explained that we would finally be moving beyond the Fornero law with the ‘quota 64’ scheme, and three days later Fratelli d’Italia explained to you that that article in the Budget Bill does not concern ‘quota 64’. You tried to appoint a ‘Padanian from Puglia’ – namely Trifone Alfieri – to ANAC, and it was pointed out to you that whilst you are the ones who must draft the laws, you must also read them; and since he had previously been head of a department for the Lega, he could not be appointed to ANAC. You said you would punish the banks, and the only thing that happened, Minister, was that the bank whose Italian identity you wanted to defend – BPM – was swallowed up by the French, whilst you stood by and watched in silence, having used the Golden Power against UniCredit.” Renzi then concluded with a dig at the affair involving the Lega’s group leader, Romeo: “The only satisfaction he derived was in taking down the poor Lega group leader, Romeo: not since the days of ‘Fatal Verona’ has a Romeo been treated so badly; we’ll call him ‘Juliet’ in private...”
Salvini, for his part, after responding to IV’s question with a series of figures, also took a dig at Renzi: “I am proud of the work that nearly 100,000 FS workers do every day in the service of Italy – we will seek to improve the service in Saudi Arabia too, a country you care so much about,” said the minister. He then went on to discuss the number of delays, which, according to the ministry’s figures, remains constant despite the increase in the number of trains in service: “We are continuing to work to reduce service disruptions; the number of passengers on trains in Italy up to 15 November this year stood at 2,666,121, compared with 2.5 million for the whole of 2022, and the increase in passenger numbers becomes even more evident if we look back over time”, therefore, “the figures on train delays – which remain constant despite the increase in trains and passengers – must be viewed in the context of these passenger volumes. In some cases, there have even been improvements”. Finally, a note on tomorrow’s strike, Friday 20 November 2026, as announced by the CGIL: “We are continuing to take practical steps to minimise disruption to the public, including in relation to strikes, whilst respecting the full freedom to join the strike called by the CGIL and other unions. For tomorrow, Ferrovie dello Stato is able to guarantee that services will run as normal. On Saturday, it will ensure that 95 per cent of high-speed trains and 85 per cent of Intercity trains run as scheduled.”
The leader of Iv, dissatisfied with the figures, retorted: “Solidarity with those who write replies to the minister who doesn’t listen and responds as he pleases. It’s not certain that if he listened he’d understand; if he went to school he’d be tested and would talk about whatever he wanted. The fact is that of all the promises he makes, he doesn’t deliver on half of them. He’s not a bad person; he just doesn’t know how, he doesn’t understand…".
The issue of train delays, on the other hand, has become a favourite topic for the Florentine senator. A few months ago, Italia Viva’s ‘2x1000’ campaign caused a stir precisely because it referred to delayed trains in a number of advertising hoardings that had ended up in Italian railway stations. 
Moving on from the trains, Renzi finally turned his attention to foreign policy. “Salvini is pleased because his great leaders, Putin and Trump, are meeting today in China. He forgets to mention that if he has the money for the construction sites, it is thanks to Europe – the very same Europe he speaks ill of, the very same Europe in which he voted against the NRRP; the very same Europe that saved Italy’s infrastructure and that will allow Salvini to leave. Of course, he’ll leave later because he wants to stand for election in November,” he concluded, “but when he does leave, in November 2027, Salvini will be the only late passenger to be seen off with a standing ovation from the commuters.”