Rome. The PD’s rejection of the anti-Semitism bill on Tuesday evening in the Chamber of Deputies, the abstention of the party’s reformists and then, yesterday morning, Lele Fiano’s tearful departure from the party. “The PD should reflect on this departure; it is a serious loss,” Piero Fassino, PD MP and former mayor of Turin, tells Il Foglio: “Fiano is a man of integrity and courage, a dear friend and a comrade with whom I have shared – and will continue to share – a political commitment. A man who has fought to ensure the PD recognises the importance of the relationship between the left and the Jewish community.” Is it not recognised? “I do not think so, and faced with a vote that highlighted the absence of that awareness, Fiano has chosen to continue his battle outside the party. I deeply regret this, and I hope that the PD leadership is aware of this, all the more so at a time marked by a staggering rise in manifestations of anti-Semitism and anti-Jewish hatred.” Fassino does not wish to discuss what he will do from now on; he is reflecting on the matter. Meanwhile, he believes that “a man of the Left cannot vote against a measure to combat anti-Semitism, even if that measure is debatable, open to criticism and amenable to amendment. He cannot, because the fight against anti-Semitism is one of the very foundations of the identity of a left-wing party and of the democratic world. And that is why I abstained”. In the Senate, last March, however, the reformist wing of the PD had actually voted in favour. Why did you choose to abstain in the Chamber of Deputies? “For two reasons: the first is that the majority rejected all the amendments that could have incorporated the suggestion put forward by Senator Liliana Segre towards a consensus text: it would have been enough to accept just one, and the measure would have been passed by a large majority. The second reason concerns the atmosphere that had developed in the chamber, which was particularly aggressive – I would say unacceptable: Pino Rauti’s inflammatory remarks, the statements claiming that the partisans were murderers. ‘You had no choice but to abstain.’ And that is not all: ‘I believe,’ says Fassino, ‘that this bill has suffered from a twofold exploitation: the exploitation by the right, which, in reality and from the very beginning, conceived the bill to regain credibility with the Jewish community, seeking to make people forget the racial laws and its complicity in the Holocaust. The second is that of many figures on the left who have conflated the anti-Semitism bill with the situation in Gaza and the West Bank – issues that bear no relation whatsoever. Opposing Benjamin Netanyahu is right; personally, I have always done so and will continue to do so. However, this must not lead to a reduction in our commitment to combating anti-Semitism; we cannot accept legitimising acts of anti-Semitism simply because Netanyahu has done what he has done in Gaza. It makes no sense whatsoever; it is an unacceptable form of exploitation, just as it is to regard any Jew as an accomplice of Netanyahu, wherever they may live in the world. This attitude, too, must be rejected.” What has changed in the Chamber of Deputies compared to the Senate? “The atmosphere, I repeat. But our abstention was not an expression of criticism or doubt regarding the bill, the contents of which we fully support; it was intended to mark a distinction from the PD and its ‘no’ vote.” Would you have voted in favour, then, had it not been for that atmosphere? “Yes, that would have been possible, but in any case our distinction is that of those who do not agree with the PD’s choice.” The unease is such that Fiano has spoken out. “Fiano, a courageous and forthright man, has always fought to build positive relations between the Jewish community and the Left. But, when he realised that the PD lacks any awareness of the importance of this relationship, he distanced himself and felt he had to continue his commitment from outside the party. I am very sorry about this; our bond of brotherhood has lasted for years and I will continue to fight alongside him, albeit in different contexts, to ensure that the relationship between Judaism and the Left is once again considered an aspect of the Left’s very identity.” Has the PD lost its way? “It has allowed itself to be influenced by AVS, the M5S and the Pro-Pal Movement. But it would be a serious mistake to subordinate a position of principle – a position that defines our identity – to mere electoral expediency.” If only the alliance between the PD, the M5S and AVS were at least solid on other fronts (see the entries on ‘Ukraine’ and ‘wealth tax’). Are we losing our collective memory, given that it seems difficult to even listen to Liliana Segre? “It’s painful to see all this, but the right also bears a great deal of responsibility: if it had accepted even one of the amendments tabled, the matter would have been resolved. It’s clear that it wanted the rift.”