Politics
The paradox •
The majority is divided over e-books, but the broad coalition saves the day. Thanks to those absent without leave
The governing coalition is falling apart but is still holding together: this is not down to a solid majority, given the number of centre-left MPs missing from the Chamber. Seven senators from the PD and four from the M5S are absent, many without justification. The centre-right’s best ally is not Calenda, but the centre-left, which is ‘absent without justification’.

“But is that part of the job?”, Checco Zalone might say. Chaos reigned in the Senate this morning. The majority lost a vote in the Budget Committee whilst discussing not the budget bill, but the Education Bill. The row had already flared up yesterday over an amendment tabled by Fratelli d’Italia seeking to introduce a requirement for schoolbooks to be sold in e-book format at half price. Forza Italia turned up its nose at the proposal; in the Senate’s ‘mini-parliament’, it voted against it, and so the majority was defeated 12 to 11. However, in the Chamber, the amendment was passed by 86 votes to 74, despite the opposition vote announced by Forza Italia’s group leader, Stefania Craxi, in the plenary session, securing two more votes from Azione. But it was the rest of the opposition – or rather, their absences, particularly from the PD and the Five Star Movement – that saved the majority.
From the attendance records examined after the vote (which was met with a roar of relief from the centre-right), several absences from the Campolarghi faction emerged. For the Democratic Party, seven senators were absent: Lorenzo Basso, Graziano Delrio, Franco Mirabelli and Anna Rossomando. They were absent without a valid reason. The other three were either on official business or on leave: Alessandro Alfieri, Simona Malpezzi and Valeria Valente (specifically, some are in Berlin today for the security summit). From Italia Viva, Ivan Scalfarotto was absent (with justification). In the Mixed Group, representing the AVS, Ilaria Cucchi was also absent because she was ‘on official business or on leave’. As for the Five Star Movement, however, none of those absent had a valid reason. We are referring to the honourable members Sabrina Licheri, Orfeo Mazzella, Roberto Scarpinato and Mario Turco. Nor were the senators ‘on loan’ from the parties to form new groups present: Andrea Crisanti (of the PD, but on loan to Acerbo), and Luigi Nave (on loan from the M5S to Onorato and Maraio). The former was absent without justification, the latter with. There were other absentees too, but they do not belong to or vote with the centre-left.
In short, today the broad coalition missed an opportunity that should have been seized immediately. And it is by no means certain that such an opportunity will arise again. Had they been present, the MPs on the long list already mentioned could have brought down the government, plunging it back into the chaos seen in July whilst the electoral law was being debated. Incidentally, most of those who did not turn up in the Chamber were absent without justification. Yet the majority’s impasse had been known for several days, just as the hurdle to be overcome in the Chamber today was well known.
Tensions were so high that Giovanbattista Fazzolari, the Under-Secretary at Palazzo Chigi, and Ministers Maria Elisabetta Alberti Casellati and Paolo Zangrillo took their seats in their respective parties’ benches to monitor the situation (although the Minister for Education, Giuseppe Valditara, was not present). Some cynics believe the whole thing is “so absurd that it must have been orchestrated”. The fact that negotiations are still ongoing, the lack of a joint programme, and the leadership yet to be established all weigh heavily on the situation.
The amendment voted on today had initially been included in the Budget Bill, but was subsequently removed. After the vote, Deputy Prime Minister Antonio Tajani played down the incident: “It wasn’t a government amendment; it was a party amendment tabled in Parliament: we started out with differences within the centre-right; it can happen that a party doesn’t vote for our amendment, and we don’t vote for another one; this has nothing to do with the stability of the majority, nor does it have anything to do with the measure itself.” Matteo Renzi has already called for his resignation. There is a sense that the end is near, and the centre-left is ‘absent without leave’.


