Inquiry committees have become committees of revenge

From Covid to the anti-Mafia movement, right through to the David Rossi case: an institution that has become a talk-fest tribunal for political score-settling. The paradox of the ‘libertarian’ right: conspiracy theories and everyone against everyone
18 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of Inquiry committees have become committees of revenge

Giuseppe Conte’s hearing before the Covid committee chaired by Marco Lisei (centre) (Roberto Monaldo / LaPresse)

A brilliant economist, now sadly missed, argued even in more innocent times that Italy was an unsolvable country because, whenever the (now defunct) ‘Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry into Terrorism in Italy and the Causes of the Failure to Identify Those Responsible for the Massacres’ was summoned to Parliament, one would invariably be met by a switchboard operator who would reply, ‘Massacres, please?’ Many years later, Italy remains an institutionally intractable country, unwilling to cooperate with any investigation undertaken in a bipartisan spirit, but there is one aspect in which the situation has actually worsened. With the advent of the Republic’s first fully right-wing government, committees of inquiry have become a talkative tribunal for posthumous revenge and political retribution, often carried out through intermediaries. This is all the more paradoxical when one considers that the right had presented itself as a champion of the sacred principles of due process, transparency, respect for institutional roles and the overcoming of that cultural hegemony which, it was said, was partly to blame for so much of Italy’s lack of transparency. Instead, Parliament has become a battleground for commissioned revenge.
Starting with the Covid Commission (in bureaucratic jargon: the Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry into the management of the health emergency caused by the epidemic spread of the SARS-CoV-2 virus and the measures adopted to prevent…’ etc.), the symbolic pinnacle of what, for the majority, ‘inquiry’ means: namely, pillorying – if it is not quite possible to put them behind bars – the alleged enemies of the people.
Not that this didn’t also happen during the First and Second Republics, of course. The partisan spirit and the punitive intent of political opponents (at least when not everything could be delegated directly to the judiciary) have always existed. One need only recall the commission on the Sifar case or on P2, or others concerning more laughable conspiracies such as the Mitrokhin affair or the commission on the Telekom-Serbia affair (coincidentally, strongly championed by the centre-right), not to mention the ‘queen’ – alongside the massacres and Mafia massacres – of all commissions of inquiry, whose remit has always straddled the line between the historical and the political: the Moro case. This case has had no fewer than two commissions of inquiry, in addition to the five court trials.
At the top of the list of the centre-right’s vindictive committees is, of course, the one on Covid, set up in 2024 – a blatant and pointless gift to the anti-vax electoral base that was clamouring for a scalp (it took two years to set it up, a sign that perhaps not everyone in the Meloni government was entirely convinced). Speaking about his own hearing, Gianni Rezza, former Director-General for Prevention at the Ministry of Health and an epidemiologist, said he had been treated “not as an expert, but as a supposed political opponent”. Scientists such as Fabrizio Pregliasco and Matteo Bassetti have denounced a climate of witch-hunting with no scientific basis whatsoever. What could (still) have been an opportunity to take stock of the decisions made has turned into a Maga-style uproar.
The Anti-Mafia Commissions, throughout their complex, contradictory and long history, have been one of the fiercest battlegrounds in political life, with judicial fallout and clashes between divergent factions within the judiciary. But under the recent leadership of Chiara Colosimo, a Meloni-aligned MP, the level of confrontation and instances of blatant direct or indirect political attacks have escalated further in recent days. It is no exaggeration to say that little interest now seems to be taken in the truth (or truths) behind our country’s tragic Mafia-related events: it has become a free-for-all amongst politicians (though these are no longer the heavyweights of the past, as in the days of the Christian Democrats and Berlusconi), amongst public prosecutors’ offices, amongst magistrates and former magistrates who have entered politics, and even amongst former state representatives, all of whom are using this situation to strike at the old enemy. This appears to be the sole rationale.
The parliamentary committee of inquiry into the death of David Rossi (every inquiry that goes nowhere now has its counterpart in a parliamentary committee of inquiry: when will we see one into Garlasco?) has officially implicated the former chairman of Montepaschi, Giuseppe Massaro, even naming him as the alleged instigator, thereby openly bypassing the role of the magistrates. Here too, it is not difficult to identify the underlying motives of political conflict. Motives which often border on conspiracy theories. For a majority that had presented itself as ‘new’, even as a defender of civil liberties (a claim thoroughly disproved day after day, measure after measure), the paradox of having transformed the rationale behind commissions of inquiry (assuming they actually have one) into acts of revenge carried out through such commissions is truly a mind-boggling paradox.
Maurizio Crippa