Futuro Nazionale must be defeated, not dissolved

The Rome Public Prosecutor’s Office has opened an investigation to ascertain the validity of a complaint lodged by the military trade union alleging that Roberto Vannacci is organising the re-establishment of the National Fascist Party. But there is an antidote to the former general’s reactionary ravings: democracy

18 NOV 26
Last updated: 18:44
Translated by AI
Gianni Alemanno and Roberto Vannacci at the ‘Forum on Italian Independence: Social Sovereignty for a True European Identity’, organised by Futuro Nazionale – Vannacci. Orvieto, Sunday 20 September 2026 (Photo: Roberto Settonce/LaPresse)Gian

Photo: LaPresse

The Public Prosecutor’s Office in the capital has opened an investigation to ascertain the validity of a complaint lodged by the military trade union, which accuses Futuro Nazionale – the political group led by Roberto Vannacci – of re-establishing the National Fascist Party. For the time being, this is a routine procedural step, and it will be up to the anti-terrorism prosecutor, Simona Marrazzo, to decide whether to enter anyone in the register of suspects. It seems highly unlikely that the proceedings will lead to a trial, let alone result in the dissolution of FN, at least judging by past precedents.
The Scelba Law, which implemented the principle set out in the final provisions of the Constitution, has been applied very rarely, partly as a result of rulings by the Constitutional Court which, as early as the late 1950s, drastically limited its application. This year alone, 12 Casapound activists were convicted in Bari. However, even in that case, the conviction was based on an attempt to organise armed groups in support of a subversive agenda. The dissemination of slogans or objectives reminiscent of those of the fascists is not considered a criminal offence, and this probably also applies to Vannacci’s reactionary ramblings. On the other hand, in a liberal democracy, one may sanction acts and behaviour that constitute a breach of the law, but not the expression of views and judgements, which may be considered unacceptable yet cannot be prevented precisely because democracy, unlike fascism, recognises the right to express any opinion. It was wise not to dissolve the Italian Social Movement, despite its positions – especially in its early stages – which were openly nostalgic, not least because, as part of the democratic process, that organisation too has evolved and transformed. Thus, a movement such as Futuro Nazionale must be defeated and marginalised using the weapons of democracy, not through the rigours of a law which, moreover, would be extremely difficult to enforce.