Politics
the interview •
Delrio: “The PD is in the midst of a civil war over the Anti-Semitism Bill”
The senator, the lead signatory of the bill rejected by his party, does not rule out a future away from Schlein: “We will postpone this discussion until the coming weeks.” He also rejects the accusations regarding the IHRA definition: “It does not prohibit dissent regarding Israel.” Reformists’ unease over the PD’s stance is growing

This is not, of course, down to some grand dogma of freedom, but rather because of the IHRA definition. The Democratic Party is voting against the anti-Semitism bill in the Chamber of Deputies, alongside Roberto Vannacci and all the other members of the broad coalition (with the exception of Italia Viva). The PD’s pretext is that the definition is too narrow, “repressive of freedom”. And now, some of the PD’s MPs and senators are the ones feeling constrained.
In fact, apart from Emanuele Fiano – who has left the PD – the rumour mill suggests there is further discontent. Is Senator Graziano Delrio, for example, still at ease within Elly Schlein’s PD? “We’ll leave this discussion until the coming weeks,” he says. And the suspicion – as has been suggested to us – is that he, too, is considering distancing himself from the party. “I’m not giving any interviews on this at the moment, I’m afraid. All the more so on the eve of the vote.” Some say, more specifically, that Delrio is looking towards the “centre” – whatever “centre” may mean – that is, towards new movements with Catholic roots. But he repeats: “Let’s see what happens, and we’ll talk about it later.” Very well.
Leaving aside his reflections on the party’s hostility, however, the Democratic Party senator does not hold back. As the promoter and first signatory of the bill, Delrio observes a “civil war” in Parliament. “A war has broken out over this definition,” he explains, “which in no way calls into question the legitimate and necessary criticism of the Israeli government – quite the contrary.”
The definition comes from the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance and is accompanied by examples of anti-Semitism, such as attributing collective guilt to Jews for Israel’s actions or applying double standards to Israel that are not imposed on other states. “A definition that in no way prohibits dissent”. And which, as you will recall, was adopted by the Conte II government. “Yes”. Well, our view is that this definition serves as a pretext within your party to avoid upsetting your allies (AVS and M5S) or public opinion. Is that the case? “I understand what you’re saying, but I try not to read too much into things. Rather, I see a serious issue.” What do you see? “A growing phenomenon affecting real, flesh-and-blood people.” Is this a phenomenon that the PD fails to grasp? “I see children who need to be escorted to school because they wear a kippah. Italian citizens of Jewish origin whose rights, culture and identity are now at risk of being trampled upon. Criticism of the Israeli government is irrelevant. If they were Italian people of the Islamic faith, it would be exactly the same. I would take the same stance.” We have no doubts.
Yet there are few in the party who share your view. Guerini, Quartapelle, Fassino and Merola in the Chamber of Deputies, and then the six senators. The question, then, is not whether you will change parties, but whether your party has changed its ways. “I do not believe, nor do I want to believe, that this is the case. I see a left in Italy that is very different from Mélenchon’s French left, where discriminatory rhetoric is theorised and justified. As I told you, I don’t look for hidden agendas. We are not France.” Of course. Even if some things in Italy take a while to arrive, they do eventually arrive. “And that is why it is important to take a step forward. To protect Jewish men, women and children who are, first and foremost, Italian citizens.”