Misiani, Orlando and the ‘Founding Fathers’-style tax model on the centre-left’s policy agenda

The broad political spectrum is grappling with income tax and wealth tax. In the 1970s, say Misiani and Orlando whilst presenting Francesco Tundo’s book (Riforma tributaria e identità repubblicana), the foundations were laid for the ‘far-reaching and bold’ reform that is needed today

17 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of Misiani, Orlando and the ‘Founding Fathers’-style tax model on the centre-left’s policy agenda
Rome. The discussion on taxation, held at the heart of the broad coalition, featured the Democratic Party’s Head of Economic Affairs, Antonio Misiani, and the Democratic Party’s Head of Industrial Policy and former minister, Andrea Orlando, who reflected on the topic with the aid of the book “Riforma tributaria e identità repubblicana”, written by Francesco Tundo, Professor of Tax Law at the University of Bologna, and discussed in the Senate by economist Lucrezia Reichlin, alongside the author and the Democratic Party representatives themselves. A look back—specifically at the 1971 tax reform—to take a giant leap forward, and precisely on the day (yesterday) when the broad coalition convened its ‘economic and tax’ roundtable with representatives from the parties (and with Misiani representing the PD). The timing is perfect, and the book’s subtitle appears tailor-made to illustrate the criticisms of the Meloni government’s budget and, at the same time, the ‘taxation and redistribution’ chapter that the Democrats would like to see in the programme: ‘Una scelta di campo contro le diseguaglianze’. What does tax reform mean? What should be included in income tax? What forms of wealth should be taxed, and how should the burden be distributed between direct and indirect taxes, and between income, wealth and consumption? We are taking a step back along the winding path of the First Republic – which today no longer seems quite so harsh – to revive the thinking of the Constituent Assembly, the work of Finance Minister Luigi Preti (who had fought for reform even before 1971) and the words of Sandro Pertini and Aldo Moro, during the years of the Piazza Fontana bombing and the ‘strategy of tension’. Even back then, there was talk, in a sense, of a wealth tax – the bane and boon of the broad coalition’s economic discussions. Indeed, there are endless variations on the word ‘wealth tax’ – a term best expressed in other terms: these range from the ‘tax on the super-rich’, favoured by the PD – an annual levy of between 2 and 3 per cent on assets exceeding 100 million euros, inspired by the model of the French economist Gabriel Zucman – to the ‘levy on assets exceeding 5.4 million euros’ (favoured by AVS) to the ‘neither one thing nor the other’ stance of Giuseppe Conte’s M5S: let’s tax financial speculation and consider a ‘sliding-scale tax system’. Tundo’s book provides Misiani, that morning, with the inspiration to outline the thrust of his speech at the afternoon’s thematic roundtable: “The current tax system,” he says, “is characterised by significant horizontal and vertical inequity; it is inefficient and heavily skewed in favour of unearned income; it requires a comprehensive, far-reaching and bold overhaul.” This brings to mind “the mass aristocratic society” (from sociologist Luca Ricolfi’s book). Between the lines one can glimpse a desire to address the IRPEF tax brackets, the flat tax and the ‘proliferation of alternative tax regimes’, the combined effect of which, in Misiani’s view, does not reflect – indeed, masks – the non-progressive but ‘regressive’ reality of the current tax system, in which it is primarily employees who are being overburdened. The priority, according to Secretary Elly Schlein, is ‘redistribution’. And at the negotiating table? ‘We will discuss matters in a dispassionate manner,’ says the Head of the Economy. For Orlando, not only is there inequality in the current system – and even more so in the centre-right’s fiscal policy – but also ‘a lack of a credible plan for the country’. On the issue of wealth, then, the starting point for the former Democratic Party minister is the imbalance of power and the need to redistribute that too (first and foremost). The priority, the Democrats say in unison, is “the overhaul of the IRPEF, moving towards a broader, fairer and more progressive tax system”. The model – for personal income tax as well as for the potential coordination of state-owned companies – is, in part, Germany. “The failure to tackle the country’s structural problems, from wage inequalities to the demographic and scale-related issues facing businesses,” says Orlando, “is directly reflected in a fragmented, corporatist tax system. A credible political project for the country and for future generations must necessarily combine economic efficiency with social justice”. We must return to the Constituent Assembly to rebuild “a republican pact founded on the original values”. Meanwhile, the tax working group has been reconvened this morning (there is some tension between the AVS and the M5S over the wealth tax, while the centrists are more focused on personal income tax than on any potential new levy). Schlein, however, prefers to see the glass as half full, insisting: “We’re working for you.”