How strange is the grunge spirit embodied by the new generation of Nirvana

Frances Bean Cobain and Violet Grohl, daughters of the same turmoil. Raised in the provinces amidst divorces, caravans and the wrong sort of fathers

17 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of How strange is the grunge spirit embodied by the new generation of Nirvana

Violet Grohl (Getty image)

Here are the daughters of grunge. January last year, Los Angeles: a charity event for the victims of the wildfires that devastated the region. On stage are the surviving members of Nirvana: Dave Grohl on drums, Krist Novoselic on bass, Pat Smear on guitar. On the mic, standing in for Cobain, are some illustrious voices: Kim Gordon, Joan Jett, St. Vincent. Then, for the final track, ‘All Apologies’, an 18-year-old girl appears, looking rather listless. It’s Violet, Grohl’s daughter.
Thirty-two years earlier, behind the scenes at the 1993 MTV Video Music Awards, another little girl was being passed from arm to arm, and Kurt would often hold her close to his chest whilst Courtney Love was busy chatting to everyone. It was Frances Bean, the couple’s only daughter, who was just one year old. Today she is 34, with a husband, a son and legal control over her father’s image. Violet, on the other hand, has just turned 20 and, at the end of May, released her debut album, "Be Sweet to Me" – a work that is surprising to say the least – which she is now taking on tour around the world. The daughters of Nirvana have grown up and are coming to terms with a legacy that, on paper, did not seem passable on.
Grunge was a rejection of rock. It was the music of young people tinged with unease, who’d grown up in the provinces amidst divorces, caravans and flawed fathers. Cobain turned this tapestry of experiences into the subject matter of his songs and an entire repertoire. He rejected glamour, the idea of rock as a status symbol built on eccentricity; for him, that sound was a necessity rather than a lifestyle choice. Thirty years on, this rejection has taken the form of a family legacy, complete with heirs, disputes over rights and lucrative anniversaries. It is a paradox, and yet the debate about ‘nepo babies’ – those who are favoured by virtue of their birth – revolves around it: certain surnames open many doors, but it is at the very least bizarre that they do so in the name of an aesthetic founded on the rejection of inherited privilege.
Frances Bean Cobain, however, inherited little more than an absence. She was twenty months old when her father shot himself, and she grew up with a tempestuous mother, a regular in the courts. She and Violet, overshadowed by an icon who continued to loom ever larger and never ceased to be radioactive. Frances made her debut as a model, wearing one of Kurt’s cardigans: a sense of belonging? Appropriation? Marketing? But then she surprised everyone by turning to painting, with an intense style characterised by dark, silent and distorted figures. When Brett Morgen made Montage of Heck in 2015 – the documentary about her father – she accepted the role of executive producer, but also confessed, somewhat sheepishly, that she wasn’t mad about Nirvana. She married Riley Hawk, son of skateboarding legend Tony Hawk – another imperial dynasty of US counterculture that has become a brand – and had a child. After an eight-year absence, she recently reappeared in public, and the newspapers could think of nothing better than to run headlines about her resemblance to her father. Now Frances is the guardian of the myth, but not the one carrying it forward. She manages Kurt’s image, keeping well clear of the reverberations of his legend.
Violet, on the other hand, has grown up in the spotlight. Dave Grohl is the ever-present godfather of contemporary rock: Foo Fighters, documentaries, memoirs, guest appearances, and the attitude of the perennial good-natured rebel. He has been bringing his daughter on stage ever since she was 14 and sang ‘Heart-Shaped Box’ at a charity concert, but now he is keen to make it clear that she made the album on her own, even though it is not easy to break free from an ever-present father. The fact is that ‘Be Sweet To Me’ is an excellent album. Recorded in the home studio of Justin Raisen – producer to Kim Gordon and Charli XCX – with a team of session musicians and specific influences: the Pixies, PJ Harvey and Soundgarden. Dirty guitars, a voice that’s at times snarling, at others dreamy, and songs about everyday objects, be it bitter nail varnish to stop you biting your nails, or a T-shirt advertising an adult hotline. Critics have been less kind, speaking of excessive embellishment and a debutante too perfect to be true. Perhaps, however, it is more appropriate to listen to her fearless challenge to the sound of the nineties – a battle in which Violet does not succumb. Because whilst talent isn’t necessarily inherited, there is a vocabulary, a wardrobe and the posturing of one’s forebears from which it’s easy to break free. Frances preserves them as an archive; Violet channels them through sound, while Gen Z continues to go mad for Nirvana. Observing the forms and fruits of these successions is a strange experience, given how it intervenes in the course of time, in cycles, in the order of things, and given how, in the meantime, the backdrop has changed, becoming something else: another America, other discontents, hardships and misunderstandings. The grunge spirit, set against the backdrop of the present, takes on naive, romantic, at times pathetic features. The survivors have the faces of old men; these sons and daughters are seized by bouts of unease. Only the dead remain intact in their eternal youth. Yet it would be perverse to rejoice in this.