Letters
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR •
A test of strength for Israeli democracy against its detractors
Who wrote to the editor-in-chief, Claudio Cerasa
18 NOV 26
Translated by AI

(Photo: Getty)
To the editor – Habsburg, yes, but around 1918.
Giuseppe De Filippi
* * *
To the Editor – Lucio Caracciolo writes in *La Repubblica* that the next Israeli government “will have to make a strategic choice: to decide whether to continue on the path of self-destruction of the Jewish state through perpetual wars with all its neighbouring enemies and some further afield, or not”. As if, since its inception, it had been Israel that had chosen its enemies and then declared war on them, rather than the exact opposite. Caracciolo goes on to emphasise that “the stakes in the battle for votes to form a majority in the Knesset, in keeping with the customs of the most unbridled Israeli-style political liberalism, are existential this time round”. Israeli-style political liberalism? One of the legendary characters played by Carlo Verdone might ask: in what sense?
Luca Rocca
Israeli democracy is demonstrating immense resilience, which is decidedly embarrassing for all those who, in recent years, have spoken and written nonsense about the Jewish state’s anti-democratic drift. The real issue, however, with regard to the future, does not seem to be so much the debate on liberalism in Israel – a debate we are happy to leave there, on the fringes, or ‘limes’ in Latin, of the ridiculous. The real issue remains another. When there is a government other than Netanyahu’s that continues to pursue a foreign policy not so different from Netanyahu’s, will those who demonise Israel have the courage to admit to themselves that their hatred of Netanyahu and their leniency towards Israel’s enemies was, and is, in reality something deeper – a more deeply rooted hatred that concerns the very right of the State of Israel to exist, and not merely to defend itself?
* * *
To the Editor – Last week’s Dublin summit demonstrated that European leaders are unable to entrust a single figure with representing their interests, both national and at EU level. In this regard, I share the concern expressed by David Carretta (Il Foglio, 16 November) that, rather than conveying a message of unity, the E7 – tasked with negotiating with Russia and the United States (France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy, Poland, the Council and the Commission) – may facilitate Putin’s attempt to divide the EU. All the more so as it is unclear to what extent Ursula von der Leyen and António Costa can speak on behalf of the other 23 Member States. The reality is that the proposals put forward by Mario Draghi and Enrico Letta to accelerate integration have so far gone unheeded. Furthermore, the reality is that the very same governments which oppose abolishing the right of veto then complain about the institutional constraints that prevent decisions from being taken. Let us make do with what we have—namely the E7 and the sensational exclusion of Kaja Kallas—but it is time for the monks to wake up.
Michele Magno
* * *
To the Editor – Social media can amplify what young people are feeling, but it is not enough to explain their anger. A lack of education may deprive them of the tools to manage their emotions, but the responsibility does not lie solely with families: it also concerns a society that struggles to convey role models, values and a sense of boundaries. Perhaps the issue is not merely that some parents have become too buddy-like with their children, but that adults, as a whole, have stopped behaving like adults.
Giuseppe Di Biasi
* * *
To the Editor – I must make a few preliminary points that are fundamental to me. My letter is not intended to spark a fruitless row, nor to diminish the scientific standing of my friend, Professor Gianni Rezza. My aim is to set aside pre-existing judgements and to look back calmly and re-examine the Commission’s hearing objectively. I speak from personal experience, having myself been questioned, insulted and verbally attacked by a member of the Five Star Movement. The tone became heated because, yet again, responsibility was shifted onto others. As regards the vaccination mandate, it is true that the decision remains a political one, but it is also true – and I hope my friend will not take offence – that he held a key technical and health-related role and, in the face of the (few) voices raising doubts about the existence of robust clinical trials, he always maintained that the risk-benefit ratio recommended its administration, despite the lack of scientific evidence at the time. Rezza became irritated when documents were requested for inclusion in the record. I realise this may seem like an accusatory approach, but it is, in fact, the proper course of action. The real problem is that this Commission is being portrayed as a tribunal instigated by the majority parties, whereas, in a normal country, it should be regarded as an important opportunity for the pandemic to leave us with vital lessons for the future. Finally, thank you to your newspaper which, unlike many others, devotes some space – however small – to reporting on the Commission.
Maria Rita Gismondo
Readers are encouraged to review the appeal launched by Professor Enrico Bucci; it offers substantial food for thought.
* * *
To the Editor – With regard to the article by Carmelo Caruso published yesterday in your newspaper, I would like to offer a few thoughts. I admit, I do many things, but between Lazio, the theatre and novels, in my spare time I also manage to devote a great deal – a very great deal – of energy and an enormous amount of time to leading the Daytime Entertainment Department. The results speak for themselves through the figures, not opinions: the credit? It may be down to luck – perhaps brazen, undeserved luck – or it may be down to an extraordinary team that delivers 70 programmes and nearly 5,000 hours of original production every year – which is a colossal amount – but the fact remains that this is the reality. Let me give you some figures: the growth of almost six points in Rai 1’s early morning slot compared to two years ago; Antonella Clerici’s top spot at midday; the significant growth of Caterina Balivo; the undisputed leadership of Alberto Matano and Marco Liorni; as well as the solid ratings we guarantee for all editions of Tg1. Weekend results include Rai 1’s leadership in the morning slot and Linea Verde’s maintenance of its position as the Sunday programme with the highest audience share across Italian television, in addition to Mia Ceran’s success in raising the ratings of Tv Talk. It may well be down to luck, but we have also dealt promptly with the recent turmoil affecting a programme of this nature, in order to protect the Rai organisation and those working on that programme, in a transparent and verifiable manner. However, as I am busy being an artist and a director seven days a week with very few breaks and very little rest, I have no time to devote to public relations or courting the powers that be to speak well of myself and ill of the rest of the world. The figures are available to everyone. I realise that, to some, a Rai executive with a background as a writer and television author who also works in theatre and music – and who, moreover, holds conservative views – might seem like some sort of Martian, an unusual figure. However, from a newspaper that claims to have a maverick and unconventional cultural stance, I would expect a little empathy… In any case, I would like to take this opportunity to invite my colleague Caruso—whose writing is always a pleasure to read—to spend a week at my side, so that he might find the answer to his perfectly valid question: But how on earth does he do it? I hope he does not require too many hours of sleep; I wake up every day before the sun rises. Warm regards.
Angelo Mellone
Carmelo Caruso replies. The sun rises and the cock crows / oh Mellone, mount your horse! We hold Mellone in high regard, and every minute of his (scant) sleep is put to good use by public television. We need his ideas and his programmes (which attract viewers). We are simply jealous of Mellone the artist and wish for the professional monogamy of Mellone the editor. In this regard, we remain sovereignists and traditionalists. We accept the invitation and propose, in place of Diaco’s ‘BellaMa’’, the new programme: ‘BellaAngelo’. A quick question, dear editor: is it true that Diaco also says, ‘If you make me angry, I’ll ring Giorgia’? That’s a good one!