Justice
The editorial from ‘L’Elefantino’ •
De Gennaro and that gunshot, which is like a toll destined to echo on
So-called procedural justice, rigged up as a pillory and a trap, almost forty years after the convictions that saved the state. Gianni De Gennaro’s suicide has shown that, in the end, the cost of living can have something apocalyptic and revelatory about it

Many now believe that life is worth no more than a dignified exit, euthanasia, and this anti-heroic view of existence may serve as consolation. Gianni De Gennaro’s suicide, however, has shown that, in the end, the cost of life – whether well spent, poorly spent, spent in pretence or spent in truth – can, by a personal and solitary decision, take on something apocalyptic, something revelatory. De Gennaro was the master of the pentiti, self-assured in his origins and his destiny, forged in a Roman Jesuit school. He was accustomed to situations which, by their very nature, lie both on this side and beyond the law, floating in murky waters and tinged by the shadow of good and evil; for only those who wish to rewrite history harbour an embarrassing, revisionist view—full of foolish fury and vanity—of the role of the law in the construction and subsequent protection of the Republics.
His police work, alongside distinguished magistrates such as the martyred Falcone with his slightly Arab-looking face, with his gentle smile and strong Sicilian character, was a deadly trap for the mafia clans, whom the political establishment and the authorities decided, at a certain point in the mafia wars, to deal with – without regard for due process – through an open, militarised defence of the Republic, via the ‘maxiprocess’ and the hunt for anti-mafia deserters. Without his operations on the ground – starting with Buscetta’s return and confessions, right through to the management of all the state witnesses, including the controversial and harrowing case of Totuccio Contorno – there would have been no maxi-trial.
Almost forty years after the convictions that saved the state, whilst those who subsequently arrested Riina (the Mori brothers, the Subranni brothers) had to face accusations of having colluded with the Mafia in trials lasting decades, and whilst the man who first tracked down Buscetta and then framed Brusca and his associates for the ‘Attentatuni’ attack, the Capaci massacre, were ensnared in what has been called procedural justice—a mechanism likened to a pillory and a trap—saw their reputation, their life by the sea and in the countryside, far more than merely compromised; they saw what they considered their fiery soul, their passion, their indiscreet and mad profession—they saw it all churned up and spat out like the prosecutor’s vomit. He must have thought how strange that country is – one which, well, may not need heroes but sends its guardians to the slaughter; strange that country which never brings a case to a definite conclusion, which, after decades, revives time-barred offences and erects gallows of paperwork and wiretaps to discredit the gods of justice in the name of the law. And all this, as judges on the right and left, the hardliners and the defenders of due process, wise old men such as Giuseppe Di Lello, is done for the sheer partisan pleasure of dipping their pens in an inkwell of blood and shit as they rewrite the history of Italy they so crave – always on the lookout for an external instigator of a massacre, always hunting for someone to throw the investigation off track, always chasing after that which can only be avoided by the protective escape of death from a life one abandons only because, deep down, it was worth it. There is no such thing as a golden handshake; some gunshots reverberate like a toll that will not cease.
More on these topics
Ferrara, Giuliano. Nato a Roma il 7 gennaio del ’52 da genitori iscritti al partito comunista dal ’42, partigiani combattenti senza orgogli luciferini né retoriche combattentistiche. Famiglia di tradizioni liberali per parte di padre, il nonno Mario era un noto avvocato e pubblicista (editorialista del Mondo di Mario Pannunzio e del Corriere della Sera) che difese gli antifascisti davanti al Tribunale Speciale per la sicurezza dello Stato.
