Justice
The comment •
Cassese explains what the new ANAC must not do
“After many years of law enforcement and numerous studies, we now have measures of actual corruption. The anti-corruption authority, rather than acting like ‘Big Brother’, must confine itself to reporting and, where possible, penalising instances of corruption, especially the most widespread ones,” the emeritus judge of the Constitutional Court tells Il Foglio
19 NOV 26
Translated by AI

Photo: Ansa
Now that the government has chosen the name to head ANAC, it is perhaps worth recalling what the Authority must not do. The name put forward yesterday by the Council of Ministers is Remo Morzenti Pellegrini, nominated by Salvini following Nuccio Altieri’s withdrawal. A professor of Administrative Law at the University of Bergamo and rector of the university from 2015 to 2021, he is vice-president of the National School of Administration. “The anti-corruption authority’s primary task is to measure actual corruption, not perceived corruption,” Sabino Cassese, emeritus judge of the Constitutional Court, legal scholar and former Minister for the Civil Service in the Ciampi government, tells Il Foglio. “After many years of enforcing the law and numerous studies, we have measures of actual corruption, not perceived corruption, and we know which types are most significant. Therefore, rather than acting like ‘Big Brother’, the anti-corruption authority must confine itself to reporting and, where possible, sanctioning instances of corruption, especially the most widespread ones.”
Back in 2017, Cassese had already highlighted in these pages the widespread suspicion, the compliance requirements imposed even on the smallest local authorities, and the risk of the ANAC overlapping with the public prosecutor’s offices and the Court of Auditors. He also suggested a solution: to staff the offices with qualified and well-paid technical personnel capable of planning, assessing and monitoring, thereby reducing reliance on external expertise. In 2020, he returned to the subject of controls designed to prevent rather than correct, and to the fear of decision-making fuelled in part by the self-aggrandising behaviour of the inspectors. The key is to demand verifiable results, proportionality and respect for areas of competence from the Authority. Increasing red tape and slowing down decision-making does not guarantee a reduction in bribery. And politicians cannot use ANAC to shirk their responsibility to ensure that local authorities function properly.