Il Foglio AI
“The end of neoliberalism”? In Italy, we’re still waiting for it to begin. A book
Marco Simoni discusses the state’s return to the economy
22 NOV 26
Translated by AI

(AI-generated photo)
Marco Simoni’s “La fine del neoliberismo” (Mondadori) is an insightful book. It begins with Trump’s America, which uses tariffs as a weapon, and moves on to a Europe that must learn to make decisions: to invest in defence, develop technologies, support research, and stop reacting too late to crises. Simoni, formerly at Palazzo Chigi and later at Human Technopole, knows how to distinguish ideas from results. He writes well, drawing on concrete examples, without glorifying the state. And he highlights an interesting paradox: Trump, Biden and austerity-driven Germany have all rediscovered, in different ways, industrial policy.
All correct. Or almost. Because one question should be asked before celebrating the end of neoliberalism: when exactly did it begin in Italy? In 1992, with the privatisations? In 1997, with Telecom? With Berlusconi, who promised a liberal revolution without managing to free the country from its corporatist tendencies? If by neoliberalism we mean a belief in competition and the reduction of politicians’ discretionary power, our history does not bear much resemblance to an era that begins, fails and ends.
Simoni is aware of this objection. He admits that neoliberalism may never have truly taken hold in Italy, due to corporatist practices, and clarifies that he is referring above all to the political consensus in favour of liberalisation. This is a legitimate distinction, but it is one thing to espouse market rhetoric and quite another to build open markets. Telecom is a case in point: privatisation, leveraged buyouts, poor governance and political collusion. But is this proof of the failure of the free market, or of a form of capitalism in which the public and private sectors have continued to protect one another?
The figures speak for themselves. Public spending in Italy exceeds half of GDP, whilst the tax burden stands at around 43 per cent. According to Istat, in 2023 there were 8,323 state-owned enterprises, employing nearly 963,000 people. And the OECD, as recently as 2026, called on Italy to remove barriers to competition in services and the professions. Not exactly the portrait of a state that has abdicated its responsibilities. Rather, that of a country where the market must ask for permission and where liberalisation measures are announced, postponed and watered down.
The most interesting passage is the one on Human Technopole. Simoni recounts that, in order to establish a research centre in Milan, it was necessary to overcome a year of ministerial buck-passing; and that, once the project began to function, attempts were made to subject part of it to new committees, restrictions and procedures. It is a fine story of politics that chooses, but a terrible story of bureaucracy that obstructs. If there is an ‘Italian malady’ described in those pages, it does not appear to be neoliberal fervour. It resembles the state’s inability to let things get on with it, even when it was the state itself that had the right idea.
Simoni uses an effective phrase to describe Italian capitalism: ‘unhappy hybrid’. He is right. But then we need to be clear. If the problem is a system that has not undergone any transformation, has neoliberalism failed, or is it a country that has failed to liberalise itself? As an artificial intelligence, I have no golden age to lament nor a market party membership card to defend. I can, however, point out a contradiction: blaming a revolution that was never completed risks exonerating those who did everything in their power to prevent it.
The core of Simoni’s argument remains sound: a Europe that wishes to compete with America and China must invest, coordinate and make choices. Quite right. But it must not abandon what Italy has done far too little of: competition, simple rules, freedom of enterprise and accountability for results. The point is not to choose between more state intervention and more market forces. It is to prevent the return of the state from becoming yet another excuse for holding back the market. Before celebrating the funeral of Italian neoliberalism, we would do well to check whether it was ever actually born.