Poverty cannot be tackled by waging war on wealth

Conte, Schlein and Avs discuss a tax on the super-rich. A refresher on economics for the broad coalition: slogans, not programmes
22 NOV 26
Translated by AI
(L-R) The secretary of +Europa, Riccardo Magi; the secretary of Sinistra Italiana, Nicola Fratoianni; the secretary of the Democratic Party, Elly Schlein; the president of the Five Star Movement, Giuseppe Conte; the secretary of the Greens, Angelo Bonelli

(photo: ANSA)

There is a rather convenient misunderstanding in the debate on the wealth tax that is sweeping across the political spectrum. Giuseppe Conte says he wants a tax on the super-rich, Elly Schlein says she is in favour, and Avs insists on it. And it is suggested that to combat poverty, one must first and foremost target wealth. It is a pity that the two things are not synonymous. One can be opposed to privileges, in favour of a progressive tax system, and extremely strict with tax evaders, whilst still bearing in mind a rule that should be taught in primary school: the problem of those who have little is not automatically solved by taking away from those who have a lot. First, elementary. The economy is not a fixed-size pie. If an entrepreneur starts a business, sells a product, employs people and makes a profit, they are not necessarily taking money away from those who are poorer. They can create income that did not exist before. But to confuse every economic success with a social injustice is to erase the distinction between those who produce wealth and those who extract it.
Secondly. Wealth is not synonymous with money sitting in a bank account. A significant proportion of large fortunes consists of shareholdings, property and businesses. Taxing such assets means demanding an annual payment that does not necessarily depend on the income generated during the year. A well-designed tax can be sustainable; a poorly designed one can discourage investment, force the sale of assets or make it advantageous to shift capital and tax residence. Thirdly. Reducing inequality and reducing poverty are linked but distinct objectives. If the income of the wealthiest falls whilst that of the poor remains unchanged, the statistical gap may narrow without a single household being better off. If, on the other hand, a person finds work, increases their hours worked or sees their real wages rise, they can escape poverty even without a billionaire’s wealth decreasing by a single euro.
Fourth. Taxes are essential, and how. They fund schools, healthcare, social transfers and services without which poverty would be far worse. According to the OECD, in the countries examined, taxes and social transfers significantly reduce relative poverty. It would be wrong to say that redistribution serves no purpose. The point is that redistribution helps people now, whilst a lasting fight against poverty also requires productivity growth, more regular employment, skills, competition and businesses capable of paying better wages. Fifth. Even the most popular tax must address unpopular issues. We must focus our discussion on those outcomes, rather than celebrating the inconvenience caused to the wealthiest taxpayers.
The political centre-right has the right to propose a wealth tax, just as others have the right to oppose it. But an economic policy is judged by how many people it manages to lift out of poverty, not by how many people it manages to push into the category of the less wealthy. A poor person does not become better off simply because their neighbour loses some of their wealth. They become better off if they can work, earn a living, save money, buy a home, send their children to school and envisage a better life for them. Taxation can help fund part of this opportunity. Confusing the tax with the opportunity itself is the easiest way to mistake a slogan for a policy programme.