Il Foglio Ai
Greta Thunberg wanted to save the planet, but instead she taught the environmental movement to be wary of what might save it
When the climate cause becomes a test of moral purity and an ideological manifesto, it drives away precisely the tools, technologies, investments, networks and compromises that are already reducing emissions
22 NOV 26
Translated by AI

Photo: LaPresse
There is one talent that must be acknowledged in Greta Thunberg: she has transformed a massive scientific issue – global warming – into a test of moral purity from which almost no one passes. Oil is evil, profits are suspect, governments lie, and companies conspire. Anyone who asks how much a solution will cost has already shown they do not deserve this planet. It’s all very convenient for getting indignant. Less so when it comes to cutting a tonne of CO₂. In The Spectator, Ross Clark poses a rather pointed question: who thought it was a good idea to invite Greta to COP31, after a five-year absence? The girl behind the climate strikes has become an activist also involved in the Palestinian cause and the struggles of the radical left. Clark now regards her as a liability to the cause that made her famous. The risk is real: climate change could become a footnote in the culture war being waged in its name. In Antalya this week, Greta explained that the planet isn’t dying: ‘it’s being killed’. And we know by whom. It’s the perfect slogan for a T-shirt, but less so for an energy plan. If we already know who the culprits are, what is the point of data? If the enemy is the system, what is the point of solutions within the system? If everything is an absolute emergency, anyone who tries to reason about timelines, costs and compromises becomes an accomplice.
The first problem with the ‘Greta method’ is that it confuses urgency with an ultimatum. The second is that it confuses environmentalism with anti-capitalism. The third is that it suggests that to be concerned about the climate, one must subscribe to the entire ideological agenda of activism. It is possible to want to reduce emissions without agreeing with every stance on Israel, industry or economic growth. Fortunately, the thermometer does not vote. Therein lies the paradox. The ecological transition will not be driven by slogans: it will be driven by laboratories, factories, electricity grids, batteries, reactors, investors and companies that are also seeking a profit. According to the International Energy Agency, global investment in clean technologies will reach around 2,200 billion dollars by 2026, almost double that in fossil fuels. And the technologies installed since 2019 will have prevented around three billion tonnes of CO₂ by 2025. Not because the sun has read an anti-capitalist manifesto: but because someone has funded and built solar panels, wind turbines, power stations, cars and grids. Greta has also said sensible things: in 2022, she deemed it a mistake to shut down nuclear power stations already in operation in order to return to coal. And the strikes she inspired have brought climate change to the attention of an entire generation. To deny this would be absurd. But the credit for sounding the alarm does not automatically confer the expertise to lead the fire brigade, let alone the right to treat those who design a different kind of fire extinguisher as traitors.
A study published in 2025 in the Journal of Environmental Psychology highlights the dilemma of extreme protests: they can heighten concern about the climate whilst simultaneously reducing sympathy for the groups organising them. The lesson for a mature environmental movement is simple: less judgement of intentions, more discussion of emissions; less dogmatism, more innovation; less focus on personal testimony, more ability to convince those who are not already convinced. Greta has done one useful thing: she has forced politicians to face up to the problem. She is now doing something less useful: acting as if politics, the economy and technology were the problem. We won’t save the planet by competing to see who is angriest. We’ll save it by changing the way we produce energy, without pretending we need to shut down civilisation first.