editorials
Are they headteachers or bad teachers? The strange case of Milan
At Bottoni High School, the headteacher has sided with the students occupying the school and criticised teachers who continue to teach remotely. But school is not a community of equals
20 NOV 26
Translated by AI

(Getty image)
Giovanna Mezzatesta, headteacher of the Piero Bottoni Scientific High School in Milan, has expressed her full solidarity with the students who have been occupying the school for three days, as has also happened at several other schools in Milan. Interviewed by Manuela Perrone in the local section of Corriere della Sera, she stated that “it is easier to show solidarity with the students than with the teachers”. Her criticism is directed at teachers who continue to carry out their teaching duties online, setting homework: behaviour which, according to the headteacher, amounts to “taking refuge in bureaucratic-digital dirigisme”.
To the students, however, she wrote: “You are calling for a school that is a critical community, a space for emancipation, an anti-fascist stronghold and a laboratory for peace. That is exactly the kind of school I believe in too”. Other headteachers of the occupied schools have expressed very different views, which is legitimate, just as Professor Mezzatesta’s solidarity is legitimate. The question that arises is whether personal political positions can form the basis of relations with the school community. Even teachers who insist on ensuring the continuity of teaching have their own opinions and act in accordance with them. One remark by the headteacher in particular deserves attention: in her view, we must not put up a wall, ‘otherwise we will only provoke further violence’. Taken to the extreme, this observation would lead us to conclude that only paternalism and acceptance of the occupations are the antidote to violence, which is clearly debatable. Understanding young people is not easy, but it is necessary. However, it is also the school’s duty to educate them, which implies imposing certain standards of behaviour to some extent. The school is not a community of equals; it requires a certain discipline that stems from a hierarchy of responsibility. This principle can be applied in various ways, but it is a little too simplistic to seek to impose a single approach on all teachers: this, too, is, at the very least, a form of authoritarianism.