Politicians pay lip service to young people, but in reality they spend on pensions

Both the right and the left want ever-increasing expenditure to be borne by those in work and those who are about to enter the labour market. But according to the FT, 80 per cent of the growth in per capita GDP from 2008 to 2024 has been absorbed by the pension system 

21 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Politicians pay lip service to young people, but in reality they spend on pensions
 Yesterday, whilst the CGIL was on strike against the Budget Bill and pension cuts, the Financial Times published an analysis by John Burn-Murdoch that addressed one of the key issues affecting us too: the trend in social security expenditure in advanced economies (in most of which pensioners have the lowest poverty rate). The article is entitled ‘How pensions have devoured the state’, and Italy is one of the most telling examples: between 2008 and 2024, real per capita GDP grew by less than 3 per cent, but the increase in pension expenditure per capita absorbed around 80 per cent of that growth. In Spain, two-thirds of per capita economic growth was channelled into pensions, and in France one-third, whilst in Germany and Sweden – where per capita GDP rose by around 11 per cent – the figure was less than one-fifth. Pensions account for around a quarter of public expenditure in Italy, France and Spain. In Italy, public pension benefits amount to 71 per cent of the average full-time worker’s pay, compared with figures ranging from 14 to 29 per cent in Denmark, the Netherlands and Australia.
On Friday, however, the banners carried by Italian students seemed to avoid the subject entirely: ‘Money for schools’. Or: ‘We want to live life without the cost of living crisis’. But if the number of pensioners is growing faster than the number of those paying in contributions, whilst wages and productivity are stagnating, funding pensions becomes more difficult. With revenue and the deficit remaining the same, spending more on pensions leaves less room for other areas, such as education and family welfare, for example.
Yet, among the demands put forward by the CGIL, which called on young people to demonstrate on what its secretary, Maurizio Landini, described as “a day that unites the generations”, there was the exact opposite of what young people actually need: from a “full revaluation of benefits” to a “freeze on the rise in the state pension age” (according to a Financial Times simulation based on Denmark’s current state pension age, which has risen to 70, France’s debt would be close to 70 per cent of GDP rather than the current 119 per cent). The government’s draft budget does not take the same approach, but within the ruling coalition efforts are now underway to find resources to ease the restrictions of Article 55 of the budget, which in 2027 provides for full adjustment to inflation only for benefits up to four times the minimum, whilst reducing it for higher benefits. Moreover, the government intends to use these savings for pensions in any case, encouraging early retirement through a dedicated fund. The broad coalition is going a step further: this week it tabled a joint amendment that completely scraps the cut to the annual pension adjustment (cost: 885 million per year) and other amendments calling for an increase in funding for early retirement.
Were it not for the fact that, according to FT data, in the 1990s, households in Italy aged over 60 were the ones spending the least, whilst today they consume more than those of working age. On both the right and the left, the word ‘young people’ crops up in every discussion. In reality, however, the policy stance of both sides increasingly entails higher expenditure for those who are already retired or about to retire, at the expense of those who are working and those who are about to start working.