Economy
The analysis •
On HSBC accounts, the G7 is taking a leaf out of Italy’s book
When the cost of debt exceeds nominal growth, primary surpluses are needed (which Italy has been achieving for 30 years). Governments, however, keep putting off making decisions, and the adjustment risks coming about through ‘market pressure’.

“To stabilise public debt, all G7 countries will have to follow Italy’s example,” states “Turning Italian?”, the note published by HSBC’s global chief economist, Janet Henry. Paradoxical, isn’t it? Italy is not held up as a model because of its debt – the highest in Europe – but because of how it manages it, given that, since the mid-1990s (pandemic aside), it has managed to run a primary surplus.
For Italy, this period was brought about by the 1992 Lira and debt crisis. Now the others too “will have to follow in Italy’s footsteps”. Interest rates on new issues “seem set to remain above nominal GDP growth” and when the average cost of debt also exceeds that growth, all other things being equal, a primary surplus is needed to stabilise the debt-to-GDP ratio. But even the United States would not manage it on nominal growth alone: according to the Congressional Budget Office, nominal GDP would need to grow by 7–8 per cent a year to stabilise the debt. In 2026, however, only the United Kingdom has introduced austerity measures to reduce the deficit.
Other countries, such as Greece and Portugal, have managed to reduce their debt through lower spending and higher growth. But this path is more difficult in ageing countries, and for most of the G7 – “perhaps for all of them” – the adjustment “will probably have to come more from the revenue side”. This is also because “it seems unlikely that AI-related gains will be as effective at generating revenue as previous transformations”. No one, however, seems “willing or able to follow Italy’s example”: governments prefer to postpone action or “pretend that growth will eventually come to the rescue”. History, Henry concludes, suggests that they will only act after “a push from the market”.