Economy
Opposition Budget •
The broad coalition presents its ‘counter-manoeuvre’, but is short of funding
Healthcare, pensions, the minimum wage. The 18 joint amendments from the broad coalition are almost the programme of a future government

Healthcare, leave, pensions, the minimum wage, education, taxation and climate. As was the case last year, the broad coalition has tabled ‘unified’ amendments to this Budget Bill (there were 16 last year and 18 this year) which highlight the centre-left’s priorities. The proposals form the basis of the coalition’s programme – which is still under discussion – although they do not constitute a genuine alternative ‘counter-budget’ to the government’s draft bill, as there is insufficient funding to support the full package.
By definition, opposition parties table amendments with the aim of having them passed individually. However, it would be impossible to approve them all, as they often rely on the same funding sources. Therefore, the focus in drawing up the coalition programme must be primarily on this issue: how to find the resources for the numerous spending proposals. The heated debate in recent days on the wealth tax – regarding its scope and revenue target – points precisely in this direction. With this caveat in mind, the amendments are nonetheless useful for understanding the areas of intervention and also some – albeit still insufficient – sources of funding for a future broad-based government.
As regards healthcare, the proposal is to increase the National Health Fund by 4 billion euros with the aim of raising healthcare spending to 7.5 per cent of GDP (from the current 6.4 per cent). Once fully implemented, this will represent a structural increase in spending of around 30 billion. The problem, however, is that a large part of the funding – 2.5 billion euros – consists of temporary measures, such as the 300-euro card for the healthcare expenses of the elderly (1.65 billion) and the fund for early retirement (0.85 billion). The amendment also includes the idea – which takes up a proposal put forward by Marco Leonardi in Il Foglio – of using the ‘Durigon fund’ to finance the reform of care for the non-self-sufficient (which was approved unanimously): in an ageing country, it makes more sense – even for those approaching retirement – to receive care when it is needed rather than retiring a little earlier. In any case, ambitious structural reforms, such as the revitalisation of the National Health Service (SSN), cannot be achieved with one-off funding. Another proposal, which is one of Elly Schlein’s key priorities, is equal parental leave (cost: 3 billion).
On pensions, the broad coalition is proposing the reintroduction of the ‘Opzione donna’ scheme (costing between 100 and 500 million in 2029) and the repeal of the clause that cuts automatic pension indexation (costing 885 million a year). The problem, in this case, concerns the funding identified in the Labour Market Exit Fund: the Durigon Fund is being used rather like Mussolini’s tanks, trotted out to finance every amendment, but it is worth 850 million over three years and can only be used once.
Another important measure is the neutralisation of the fiscal drag, which costs 4.5 billion: this measure is also annual, and the funding comes from an increase in the Tobin tax (from 0.4 to 1 per cent, more than double the 0.8 per cent already planned by the government) and from a tax on the windfall profits of energy companies (including renewable energy firms). The one-off tax on Big Energy is also presented as funding for various amendments, proposed by the AVS, such as the one for adapting to climate change in urban areas and the one for mitigating hydrogeological risk.
There are some issues regarding the coverage of the two amendments proposed by the M5S, which reallocate 2.6 and 4 billion respectively from the defence budget to those of education and healthcare. The issue arises with regard to compliance with European rules: defence expenditure is covered by the safeguard clause and, therefore, redirecting it elsewhere would constitute a breach of the Stability Pact and lead to a return to the infringement procedure (even before the country has exited it).
Turning to the coverage, there are a few new developments. The first is the absence of the usual cut to environmentally harmful subsidies (SAD): ever since the National Audit Office asked for explicit details of which environmental taxes should be increased, the ‘wild card’ that has historically featured in the programmes of the broad coalition parties has disappeared. This is because everyone wants to cut SADs in general, but no one wants to specify which ones. The other interesting aspect concerns the fact that the broad coalition wants to reduce the flat tax for the self-employed, not only by scrapping the government’s planned increase to 100,000 euros, but by bringing the threshold back down to 65,000 euros (400 million in expected additional tax revenue), as it was under the Conte government. However, this also means lowering it in real terms, because the 65,000 euros of 2019 is worth almost as much as the 85,000 euros of the current threshold. This decision runs counter to the proposal on the minimum wage – increased from 9 to 10 euros an hour – and to the proposal to neutralise the tax drag: only for VAT-registered self-employed individuals is there no adjustment for inflation; in fact, the opposite is true.
The programme has not yet been finalised but is beginning to take shape, with its winners and losers.
More on these topics
Cresciuto in Irpinia, a Savignano. Studi a Milano, Università Cattolica. Liberista per formazione, giornalista per deformazione. Al Foglio prima come lettore, poi collaboratore, infine redattore. Mi occupo principalmente di economia, ma anche di politica, inchieste, cultura, varie ed eventuali
