Economy
THE INTERVIEW •
From Eni to Ilva: ‘More power to the market’. Investment banker Giovanni Tamburi speaks out
“There is a cross-party movement of savers who are just waiting for this,” the investment banker tells Il Foglio. Criticism of political capitalism, the 1,500 billion sitting idle in current accounts, and opportunities for Italian businesses

(Photo: Ansa)
“Instead of doubling the Tobin Tax or inventing an exit tax, the advice I would give the government is simple: get back to work on the privatisation dossier. There is a cross-party group of savers who are just waiting for this. They would immediately buy shares in Leonardo, Eni, Enel, Poste Italiane or Enav. The holdings managed by the Ministry of Economy and Finance (MEF) are worth around 50 billion; if 10–20 per cent were sold, the proceeds could be collected within 48 hours.” Giovanni Tamburi is one of Italy’s most astute investment bankers; he maintains just the right level of media presence and is the standard-bearer for a patient form of capitalism that invests with a view to the medium-term development of companies (and abhors hit-and-run tactics). His firm, TIP (Tamburi Investment Partners), has, to give just one example, nurtured Prysmian, which has become Italy’s leading private company by turnover.
In the 1990s, alongside Giuliano Amato and Luigi Cappugi, he was also the architect of the first privatisation law, and today he is drawing on that experience to advise the Meloni government. “If I were in their shoes, I’d draw up a plan to reduce the state’s stake in state-owned companies. In the case of the defence industry, I’d retain a golden share at most.” Tamburi recounts that in the 1990s, opponents of privatisation even claimed that selling Eni and Enel was unconstitutional; yet “we saved Italy from a financial standpoint and revitalised the markets, which had been stagnant”. Today, rather than treating state-owned enterprises as a political fiefdom, the government should move in the same direction, rather than scraping together a few hundred million by raising taxes. “Operations such as those we carried out with Eni and Enel have proved to be success stories. The companies have grown, they are generating profits, and the government continues to hold a significant stake in their capital.”
Have Eni and Enel, in the meantime, themselves become powerful forces – the cornerstone of that political capitalism which ultimately stifles the Italian system? Tamburi replies: “It is clear that there is a game of power and favours between them and the government, a system of mutual protection. And this ends up undermining the stock market because, ultimately, appointments are made by the government. Personally, I would retain a golden share for strategic decisions, but I would ensure that the lists for the board of directors were drawn up by the market. In this way, I would loosen politics’ grip on businesses. Eni, Enel, Leonardo and Fincantieri should become genuine public companies. And many other firms should be listed on the stock exchange.” Even Ilva, Europe’s largest steelworks, “had it not been run into the ground”, could have become a public company listed on the Milan Stock Exchange. We are the most thrifty nation of all; the middle class saves and the wealthy save, yet nobody takes care of them. For this reason, a few months ago Tamburi commissioned Renato Mannheimer to carry out a survey, which revealed that 45 per cent of Italians would vote for a party that favoured the inflow of capital into businesses. “I sent it to Renzi but he didn’t reply. And in any case, at the top of both the government and the opposition, there are no leadership groups that share this culture of the market and saving. Unfortunately, political competition does not centre on the very issues that are needed to pay salaries, despite the EU’s call to bring savings and businesses closer together. Instead, the talk is only of taxing windfall profits and introducing a wealth tax.” Yet during the banking crisis, the government repeatedly stated that its actions were aimed at safeguarding Italian savings and preventing them from falling into foreign hands.
“Risiko has been driven by the power dynamics and interests of the individual banks involved. The statements regarding Italians’ savings were merely window dressing. Just think: pension funds invest less than 3 per cent in companies in the real economy and send those savings to the United States, channelling them through various Fidelity funds.”
But let’s get back to Prysmian and the ‘great companies’. ‘I’ll say this without hesitation: if it weren’t for us, it wouldn’t have become what it is today. Even Goldman Sachs, which controlled it previously, failed to develop it, behaving like the most traditional of private equity firms, just waiting to exit. There are plenty of companies like Prysmian out there.” Tamburi points out that his firm, TIP, is Italy’s second-largest institutional investor after CDP, “but we’re still just a tiny player”. A tiny player that has managed to bring together 100 entrepreneurial families, steering the transition from vast wealth to industrial projects. This has given rise to success stories such as Interpump and Amplifon.
“There are 1,500 billion of Italian savers’ money sitting idle in bank current accounts; this represents a cost for the banks and generates no revenue for the Treasury. If it were invested in the Prysmian companies of tomorrow, it would not only generate growth and jobs but also revenue for the tax authorities.” But there was a mechanism to carry out this operation: the PIRs. Why didn’t it work? “They went well at first, but then the banks imposed excessively high fees and dried up the inflows. They should have been less greedy. Now Minister Giorgetti says we’ll be introducing the SIAs – let’s hope so. We need to make the most of savings if we want to move away from a GDP of zero point something.”
Let’s also discuss the responsibilities of private individuals. What is Tamburi’s analysis of the Exor/Stellantis case? “Take Elkan, for instance: he can be blamed for selling off companies like Comau and Iveco, but in the car industry, it was the Germans who brought it upon themselves with their reckless handling of the transition to electric vehicles. And now we’re only just beginning to pay the price, with Chinese BYDs popping up everywhere.”
Stellantis has fallen victim to European demagoguery, poorly led by the Germans. But aren’t private individuals also to blame for failing to manage succession properly? It is not just the Del Vecchio case that is making headlines, but also lesser-known examples such as the Stevanato family feuding. “Succession issues should be tackled by facilitating IPOs on the stock exchange. We need a law that offers tax incentives to those who pass on their business or merge it with another. Generational handover and company size must be addressed and resolved together to streamline the system and create stronger market leaders. We must do this because China is catching up.” But instead of numerous IPOs, we are seeing many delistings. Couldn’t the stock exchange also be partly to blame if European savings are flowing to the United States at a rate of 500 billion a year? “Euronext’s management of the stock exchange has prioritised its own profit and loss account over the promotion of IPOs. But I know they are now giving the matter some thought. Excessive bureaucracy and high costs have stifled the flow of listings and demotivated industrialists. I think the Stock Exchange, Consob and other stakeholders need to talk to one another and sit down around a table. At Tip, we have at least 10 listings ready. If we have ten, there must be at least a hundred on the market.”
Some argue that, ultimately, a private equity fund is preferable to the stock market. You take the opposite view. “I recognise that these funds have opened up the market to the wider world, but they have often simply extracted money from companies – in many cases, they have fleeced them. They have become rich whilst leaving the companies poorer. They have charged exorbitant fees.”
It is no surprise that private equity has taken a hit today and, above all, that exit deals have slowed down. “There are five trillion dollars’ worth of unsold assets. Funds are forced to sit on companies that were presented in one light but are actually worth 50 per cent less. The greed for money has betrayed private equity, and today it is in dire straits, with insurance companies no longer investing in them. Meanwhile, the fund managers have become incredibly wealthy. Mind you, I’ve become rich too, but I’ve guaranteed an 18 per cent return to my investors.” Financial individualism has caused failures and paralysed the system. “They’ll be forced to sell the companies they’ve taken on at bargain prices, and so the next Prysmian or Interpump will come from there. Many Italian firms will be able to buy out their competitors at bargain prices.”
A new player is emerging on the market: family offices. “It’s a very significant player. I was among the first to believe in it. Families such as the Marzottos, the Manulis and the Dompès. These are family fortunes built on industry who aren’t keen on investing in CCTs; they prefer to stay within a world they know. This is also how good industrial policy is made, and in fact family offices are increasingly replacing private equity.”
So, long live patient capitalism? “We’ve been with Interpump for 25 years, with Amplifon and Moncler for 15, with Prysmian for 12–13, with OVS for 6 and with Bending Spoons for 7. And we have no intention of selling. We work on long-term projects and mergers.” I agree on the need for foresight and the pursuit of scale, but faced with the rise of China, will the specialisation model of our ‘Made in Italy’ sector have time to reposition itself, or will it be crushed? “We need to know what we want. If we want to compete with them on humanoids, I reckon it’ll be tough; if we want to become assemblers and distributors of Chinese products, that’s a realistic scenario.” Even in the car industry? “Certainly. Filosa is quite right to say so. With Leapmotor, Cassino will be revitalised, and BYD is looking for factories in Europe. Let’s be clear, though: in certain niche markets, we’re still better than the Chinese. Amplifon is the world leader, and Moncler has opened the world’s largest shop in New York. These won’t become Chinese. If you’re good, you’ll still come out on top. There’s still industrial value in Italian and European companies.”
Let’s finish with a question about artificial intelligence. Is it true that you consider it a bubble? “I’d say that investment in AI and data centre planning has been excessive. And in fact, the trend is now levelling off. Data centres are coming up against regulations designed to govern their relationship with resources and the local area. We mustn’t block them or become like the No Tav movement, but we do need to exercise a sense of proportion.”