Italy’s growth is being affected more than elsewhere by the energy crisis and its dependence on gas

According to the EU Commission’s autumn economic forecasts, growth is expected to exceed expectations despite the energy crisis. Brussels emphasises that “in the long term, the key is the transition”; electricity from non-fossil fuel sources reduces the impact of international gas prices. 

18 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of Italy’s growth is being affected more than elsewhere by the energy crisis and its dependence on gas

(Photo: Ansa)

Italy is the European country hardest hit by the energy crisis. Nevertheless, growth is exceeding expectations, thanks mainly to the strong performance of exporting companies: 1 per cent in 2026; 0.7 per cent in 2027 and 0.8 per cent in 2028. This, in a nutshell, is the message that emerges from the autumn economic forecasts published yesterday by the European Commission.
The report devotes a feature to energy, highlighting how the Old Continent finds itself at the centre of a perfect storm: first Covid, then the war in Ukraine, and finally the blockade of the Strait of Hormuz have subjected our economic system to an unprecedented stress test. In some cases, the shock has far-reaching repercussions: oil prices and refining margins are soaring worldwide. In other cases, the problem is particularly acute within the EU: gas prices have returned to levels not seen since 2022. Whilst largely in line with those in the Far East, they remain a multiple of those in North America, where abundant production and constraints on export capacity create a favourable situation for consumers. However, within the EU there are no particular differences, at least when the transmission networks are not congested – which is not usually the case. The most serious problem concerns the varying levels of storage – with Italy commendably above 90 per cent and Germany at historic lows – which could create further tensions in the event of a harsh winter.
When it comes to electricity, however, the picture is quite different: prices have soared due to “the impact of last summer’s extreme weather events. Severe heatwaves drove up demand for electricity for air conditioning, whilst widespread droughts affected hydroelectric generation and limited the availability of water for nuclear power stations”. This has acted as a multiplier in passing on TTF price peaks to wholesale electricity prices, a phenomenon particularly pronounced in countries that are more heavily reliant on gas. Consequently, “substantial differences remain in forward electricity prices, with Germany and Italy at a significantly higher level throughout the forecast horizon”. Consequently, “in October, wholesale electricity prices averaged 220 euros/MWh, 45 per cent higher than the Iberian market, 35 per cent higher than France and 30 per cent higher than Germany”. This difference is mainly due to “past investments in renewable energy and nuclear power”, which limit exposure to gas, to the extent that over the next three years “Italian forward prices will be 60 per cent higher than their Iberian counterparts”.
In reality, the forecasts focus on wholesale prices, whilst end customers see different figures on their bills – figures that are closer to one another than one might imagine. According to the latest Eurostat data – relating to the first half of 2026 – an Italian household spent around 359.8 euro/MWh on electricity (including taxes and charges), which is 8.8 per cent more than the EU average, 15.8 per cent higher than a German household, 12.6 per cent higher than a Spanish household and 17.5 per cent more than a French household. The difference exists, but it is not as stark as one might think. Furthermore, it could narrow slightly in the coming months if the ‘Bollette’ decree delivers the hoped-for results, although quantifying the discount is complex, uncertain and very limited (in the region of 10 euros per MWh).
Brussels emphasises that “in the long term, the key is the transition”. This is partly true: increasing the share of electricity from non-fossil fuel sources, by definition, reduces the impact of international gas prices. But this benefit will diminish once gas markets return to normal: the Commission itself warns that “a sharp drop is expected in mid-2027, when new global LNG supply is expected to become available”. Decarbonisation has value in its own right, but we must not take it for granted that it will automatically lead to lower prices. A more balanced energy mix does, however, offer other advantages, including reduced volatility: therefore, as the experts at the Berlaymont Building point out, increasing the share of renewables and nuclear power acts as a sort of insurance policy against emergencies.