Economy
The analysis •
Italy and the snowball effect on the accounts. The risk of an avalanche
Europe’s highest debt and interest rates rising to 4.6 per cent are forcing the country to achieve a substantial primary surplus

The European Commission’s autumn forecasts bring two pieces of good news as the parliamentary term draws to a close. The first is that the Italian economy will grow by 1 per cent this year, double the figure forecast in the spring. The second is that the deficit, which has fallen from 8.1 per cent of GDP in 2022 to 2.9 per cent by 2026, will enable Italy to exit the European excessive deficit procedure (provided the forecasts are confirmed by Istat in the spring). As the Commissioner for the Economy, Valdis Dombrovskis, has emphasised, this is a significant achievement. But the good news essentially ends there, because the picture emerging for the following years is far less reassuring. And above all, it should prompt the political parties to exercise a degree of caution when drawing up their list of election pledges.
Italy’s problem is called public debt. In the 1990s, reducing it was at the heart of the political programmes of the two coalitions vying to govern the country: that is no longer the case. Yet, this very year, Italy has overtaken Greece to take first place in the European Union (and second in the world after Japan) in terms of the ratio of public debt to GDP: 137.9 per cent. A less-than-enviable record, which, according to Brussels, is set to worsen: the debt will rise to 138.8 per cent in 2027, before stabilising at 138.2 per cent in 2028.
In short, ten years after the pandemic, the debt will still be well above the 2019 level, when it stood at 134 per cent of GDP. The effects of the Superbonus tax credits are also a factor, continuing to weigh on the public finances despite the building bonus scheme now being a thing of the past, and spreading the final instalment of 20 billion over ten years serves no purpose: the debt monster remains stuck at 138 per cent.
But the real pitfall lies in the cost of this debt. Rising interest rates – driven by inflation and geopolitical and financial uncertainties – combined with the enormous stock of debt securities requiring financing and refinancing, will cause debt servicing costs to rise progressively. This is a trend affecting the whole of Europe, but one which takes on particularly worrying proportions for Italy. The Commission reports that between 2025 and 2028, interest expenditure will rise by almost one percentage point of GDP: from 3.8 per cent in 2025 to 4.6 per cent in 2028; 103 billion next year, 112 billion in 2028 (and then 117 billion in 2029). This is more than the country spends on education, and more than the combined total of resources allocated to defence and law and order.
The issue is not merely that Italy will have to pay ever-higher interest rates. It is the mechanism that is triggered when the average cost of debt exceeds the rate of economic growth. With weak nominal growth and such high interest rates, the so-called ‘snowball effect’ becomes unfavourable: even without new expenditure or new deficits, the debt-to-GDP ratio tends to rise. To halt this trend, it is therefore necessary to generate substantial primary surpluses – that is, revenue exceeding expenditure net of interest payments. It is not enough simply to balance the books: the country must systematically spend less than it takes in, and do so for many years. Much as the country did in the 1990s, following the lira crisis, in order to join the euro.
Under these circumstances, generating substantial and growing primary surpluses is not a matter of economic policy choice, but a necessity. And this is where the Commission’s forecasts become even more significant. Italy’s primary surplus, which is expected to stand at 1.2 per cent of GDP in 2026, is set to fall to 0.8 per cent in 2027 as a result of increased expenditure on defence and energy security covered by the safeguard clause. The picture, therefore, is of a country that must consolidate its accounts, but which at the same time finds itself having to finance new priorities and sustain rising interest payments. It is a scenario that should bring economic policy back to the reality of budgetary constraints and lead it to consider, rather than redistributing resources that do not exist, which reforms could boost productivity and the economy’s growth potential. Instead, in the early skirmishes of the election campaign, we are already hearing proposals for new spending, tax cuts and measures favouring one group or another.
Nor is it necessarily the case, as many fear, that fiscal consolidation will stifle growth: the five countries that will have the highest primary surpluses in 2027 – namely Cyprus (4.2 per cent), Greece (3.7 per cent), Portugal (2.1 per cent), Ireland (2 per cent) and Denmark (1.3 per cent), are also among those which, according to the Commission, will experience sustained growth (3.9 per cent in Ireland; 3 per cent in Cyprus; 1.5 per cent in Greece; 2 per cent in Denmark; 1.9 per cent in Portugal).
Otherwise, there is a risk of going down a path similar to that of France, where out-of-control public finances and ill-advised proposals are leading to a rise in interest payments that makes fiscal consolidation increasingly difficult. Paris now finds itself trapped in a spiral in which spending cuts and tax rises are struggling to offset the rising cost of debt. But there is one fundamental difference: Italy’s debt is already much higher than France’s, which is projected to exceed 120 per cent. Whilst for France the snowball has begun to roll in a worrying manner, for Italy it may soon turn into an avalanche. Election manifestos should start from this point: not from what to promise, but from how much scope there is for those promises.
More on these topics
Cresciuto in Irpinia, a Savignano. Studi a Milano, Università Cattolica. Liberista per formazione, giornalista per deformazione. Al Foglio prima come lettore, poi collaboratore, infine redattore. Mi occupo principalmente di economia, ma anche di politica, inchieste, cultura, varie ed eventuali
