Now that even Tg1 has discovered K-pop – a major splash for the exclusive interview with StrayKids, “the boyband that epitomises Korean K-pop ahead of the Italian leg of their tour”, which, however, will take place in July, when schools are fortunately on holiday. Now that South Korea—forgetting K-pop for a moment—has adopted a hard line against anyone caught using AI in university entrance exams (do you remember the bitter tears over the medical school entrance exams set by the sadistic Bernini?). Now that yet another nine-year-old has terrorised Castelfidardo with a photo of a snake emerging from a toilet – though it was actually AI – one might well ask what responsibility actually entails.
If a nine-year-old child can be so adept at using AI-generated photos, two distinct sets of questions arise. The first and most obvious: if a child risks knowing more than aspiring first-year university students in South Korea (a country with a toxic level of meritocracy we cannot even begin to imagine), what might happen when, instead of alarmist emails, the new generations of bright minds move on to something more serious? The second question is only touched upon by Professor Paolo Clini, director of the Artificial Intelligence Department at the Marche Polytechnic: “We must ask ourselves why a nine-year-old is accessing these tools.” Indeed, but the simplest and most direct question is: will anyone enforce the laws on causing undue alarm, for which it is not the child but those exercising parental responsibility who are accountable?
These are just a few examples plucked at random to highlight an often-overlooked issue: who bears responsibility for people’s behaviour? Moving on to a different sector, there is the case of the two graffiti artists – not exactly youngsters – who were seriously injured after falling from the roof of the occupied University of Turin: “They are two fellow graffiti artists,” said the students in their defence; they wanted “to make this place more beautiful, liveable and accessible”. Or even one from which one might fall. The Minister for Universities intervened, emphasising that an occupation cannot mean turning a “safe space into a dangerous place” and, moreover, in cases of accidents such as these, the police seize the building for investigations – but her intervention was rebuffed: the occupation continues. Who takes responsibility, and for what? In a country where any hint – we shan’t say of Korean-style intransigence, but of control, for example in schools – is interpreted by the progressive educational establishment as a sign of authoritarianism.
Once again, we are grateful to Il Corriere, which yesterday published an interview with lecturer and researcher Caterina Donattini, who analysed “disciplinary notes over two academic years at a technical and vocational college on the outskirts of Bologna”. The article begins, needless to say, by emphasising that “for the same offence, students from migrant backgrounds are suspended for more days”. Moreover, these disciplinary measures have “the opposite effect and risk excluding precisely the most vulnerable pupils”. The observation that “the teacher’s educational role is increasingly being outsourced to other bodies: social services, neuropsychiatry departments and the police” is a valid one. Except for the reference to the police: how many arrests have we actually seen in schools?
The result of a questionnaire in which teachers admit that suspensions and demerits are ineffective is also quite obvious: ‘insofar as they do not fulfil the educational purpose they are intended to serve, namely to change pupils’ behaviour and make schools safer’. Everyone can understand this. But is it certain that the opposite approach would work better? One might also question this finding from the study: ‘70 per cent of demerits punish entirely ordinary and non-dangerous behaviours such as moving about, talking, laughing, using a mobile phone, sleeping, eating or arriving late’. All of these, it seems, are commendable behaviours that should not be penalised. Perhaps they should be encouraged? After all, what harm is there in sleeping in class? What if it turned out that sleeping in class is actually a disadvantage, particularly for the most vulnerable pupils? What if the aim were (also) to instil even a modicum of a sense of responsibility?