Economy
SoundCheck •
The ‘Fondo Valore’ scheme for newborns is a good initiative, but it deserves more
From next year, the state will pay 100 euros a year until the age of eighteen for every child born, and families will be able to supplement these payments with tax incentives. The measure could serve as a tool to promote a culture of saving and long-term investment, but its management is centralised and closed to the market

One hundred euros a year until the age of eighteen does not change a person’s life. But eighteen years of small contributions can teach a family how saving and long-term investment work. This is the aim behind the Fondo Valore nuovi nati (Newborns’ Value Fund), introduced by the budget. From next year, for every child born, the state will pay 100 euros a year until they reach the age of majority. This small initial sum is intended to be transferred at the age of eighteen into a supplementary pension scheme, or to be withdrawn to pay for university studies or to set up a business. Parents, relatives and other family members will be able to add their own funds, whilst benefiting from a tax deduction.
Intuition has its value. In a country where household savings often remain sitting in current accounts, encouraging parents to invest a sum on behalf of their children can help foster a different financial culture. The problem is how to go about it. The draft bill entrusts the financial management of the funds to Cassa Depositi e Prestiti, without specifying how they will be invested, whilst the INPS is responsible for collecting contributions and handling administrative matters. This centralised solution risks losing the very most interesting aspect of the initiative: the direct involvement of families in financial decisions.
Management could instead be opened up to the market, thereby stimulating competition. Every family should be able to choose which bank, management company or pension fund to invest their child’s capital with, from a list of authorised operators. They should be able to select a risk profile, compare costs, monitor the performance of the investment and change providers over the years. A similar model already exists in Israel. Since 2017, the government’s ‘Savings Plan for Every Child’ scheme has provided a monthly payment for all children. At birth, parents can choose whether to allocate the savings to a bank account or a pension fund, whilst also selecting the investment profile. The United Kingdom has also trialled a similar scheme with the Child Trust Funds, introduced in 2005. The state made an initial contribution for each child, with a higher amount for low-income families. Parents could choose whether to leave the money in a savings account or invest it in financial products and diversified funds. The British experience, however, also suggests a need for caution: subsequent evaluations found no significant increase in household savings rates, and many parents lost track of the accounts. Freedom of choice, on its own, is not enough. Information, transparency and user-friendly tools are needed.
Italy would, moreover, have yet another reason to invest in this area. In the OECD’s international survey on financial education, our country scored just 53 out of 100 on the overall adult financial literacy index. Italy ranks last amongst the organisation’s member countries. These figures highlight a widespread difficulty in understanding financial products, risks and decisions.
This is why the Fondo Valore Nuovi Nati fund deserves a more ambitious structure. Competition amongst operators could encourage greater attention to costs and the quality of services. Each family would have a point of contact for discussions, a regular statement to review and a choice to make. Their child’s savings would thus also become an opportunity to learn how to distinguish between a deposit and an investment, a nominal return and a real return, and an expensive product and an efficient one. Families who so wish could also take advantage of the eighteen-year time horizon for diversified equity investments. Such a long period does, in fact, allow for better absorption of market fluctuations and the potential to target higher returns than those traditionally offered by CDP.
Naturally, opening up the market requires certain safeguards. The state should establish strict criteria for the admission of operators, cost caps, standardised disclosure requirements and a supervisory system. It should also provide a low-cost default option for those who do not wish to or are unable to choose, thereby preventing the initiative from becoming an opportunity to sell financial products to less well-informed households. Especially in a country like ours, where fees on financial products are already among the highest in the world.
After all, the public contribution accumulated over eighteen years will amount to 1,800 euros, net of any returns and gross of the effect of inflation. This figure is unlikely to be decisive for a young person’s future. The programme’s greatest value may lie in the habits it helps to foster. Because the real return on the 100 euros could be a generation of families who are more aware of how to invest their savings.