Meloni and business: a half-baked idyll. Looking beyond the applause

The Prime Minister is on an election tour of the business sector, which already adores her (thanks to stability and international relations). But when it comes to energy, investment and competition with China, a genuine industrial policy is needed

16 NOV 26
Translated by AI
Image of Meloni and business: a half-baked idyll. Looking beyond the applause
Her most recent visit was a closed-door meeting with the management of Conserve Italia in San Lazzaro di Savena, on the outskirts of Bologna. Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni began several weeks ago what can clearly be described as an election tour, which sees her addressing all the meetings of employers’ associations, visiting trade fairs of every kind and scale, and visiting individual companies that are brought to her attention in the regions she is already due to visit for other institutional commitments. And on every occasion, the welcome she receives is more than warm. Members of Confartigianato and CNA showered her with thunderous applause, as did the most demanding Milanese entrepreneurs from Assolombarda; at Fieracavalli in Verona, she presented photographers with the image of a horsewoman mounting a steed.
And then there’s the agricultural machinery fair, the rice producers’ fair, and the innovative companies of Eastern Piedmont. The only commitment she had to turn down, due to unavoidable commitments in Rome, was attending the ground-breaking ceremony for Silicon Box, the factory that a Singaporean microchip manufacturing group is building on the outskirts of Novara. Giorgia is everywhere, then. Her specific aim is to keep a close eye on everything happening in the business world and, politically, to definitively supplant the Lega in representing the interests of northern entrepreneurs and severing any remaining ties between them and the leaders of the broad coalition.
But why are business leaders so enamoured with Meloni? Have they found in her government the supportive administration they need at a time marked by extreme uncertainty? Do they recognise her expertise in industrial affairs, which makes her the preferred interlocutor over the erratic Matteo Salvini or the ‘radical chic’ Elly Schlein? No, the impression is that what prevails is her stature as a leader capable of sitting at any international table. Alvise Biffi, president of Assolombarda, even told her: “You have no idea how many doors open when you mention your name.” Meloni’s (necessary) focus on the major issues of war and diplomacy has worked in tandem with another major asset: political stability. By nature, business leaders do not like to see Palazzo Chigi change hands too frequently, and those who travel the world’s markets to export even more take pleasure in feeling part of a ‘normal country’. The reasons for the alliance between business leaders and Meloni end there, however, because one can say many things, but certainly not that the government, which has been in office for four years, has skilfully handled matters of industrial policy. When discussing this shortcoming of the executive, the tendency is to pin the blame entirely on Minister Adolfo Urso, who is unanimously deemed unsuitable for the role he holds and more interested in giving interviews full of empty promises than in making a tangible impact on the issues at hand. Yet industrialists, who are accustomed to reshuffling their organisational charts when necessary without shedding a tear, are wondering why Meloni has not changed horses mid-race by offering Italian business another figurehead. The most striking example was the revival of ‘Transizione 5.0’, which took shape through a scheme – that of ‘hyper-depreciation’ – suggested by former minister Carlo Calenda. A fact that Giorgia Meloni has never denied.
To continue our review, we must now ask ourselves how Italian companies are faring amidst this perfect storm of wars, the blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, soaring energy prices, the flood of Chinese goods onto European markets and the rapid advance of artificial intelligence technologies. In this regard, a seminar-style presentation delivered in Milan in recent days by the research department of Intesa Sanpaolo and Prometeia may prove useful; during the event, economists Gregorio De Felice and Alessandra Lanza, amongst others, took the floor. Let us start with the heart of the Italian industrial system: SMEs. The first thing to note is that we are not witnessing a mass closure of small businesses, as happened, for example, in the aftermath of 2008 when the Chinese took over much of our low value-added manufacturing (insulated bags, candles, umbrellas and so on). Today, we have healthy SMEs, better capitalised than in the past, often integrated into successful supply chains, with a more well-rounded financial culture, and which have a single real Achilles’ heel: the advanced age of their owners and a generational handover that is still largely to be completed. Consequently, we could see the absurd situation where, due to energy costs, some SMEs end up closing down whilst still solvent, or end up selling before they suffer serious damage. In a world characterised by the so-called ‘permacrisis’ (a portmanteau meaning ‘permanent crisis’) and the growing dominance of large-scale enterprises, SMEs have reduced their leverage by making do with fewer investments and have therefore pursued a ‘selfish’ drive for efficiency that does not bet on the future.
Let us now turn to another crucial segment of Italian manufacturing: ‘pocket-sized’ multinationals. According to Alessandra Lanza, they have managed to tackle challenges we could not even have imagined: as part of long value chains, these ‘pocket-sized’ multinationals have learnt on the fly to be extremely flexible and to reposition themselves geographically, opening up new markets both as sales outlets and as sources of supply. They have learnt to manage their warehouses differently by increasing stock levels, shelving lean production and bearing the costs of these choices – all in a world of rising interest rates and inflation. All this leads industrial economists to say that these champion exporters of ours are holding their own, are among the most competitive companies and, for now, have even resisted the temptation to sell. From my experience as a reporter, I would add that many of them are even planning to double their turnover in the coming years, are opening up their boards of directors to external members and are keeping a close eye on private equity funds – if not the stock market. They have, in fact, plenty of reserves thanks to the margins they have achieved and can comfortably weather the challenges of 2026 and 2027, perhaps merely by reducing their EBITDA.
Then there are the large companies which, according to experts, have suffered more than SMEs but are still posting healthy figures. They have certainly invested more than others in the energy and digital transitions; they have adopted labour hoarding policies, retaining even surplus staff to avoid the risk of staff shortages; and their actions have been affected – obviously to a greater extent than SMEs – by the contradictory market regulation decisions made by international bodies. The automotive sector is clearly on the brink, with regulatory uncertainty dragging on, but it can be argued that the large firms have nevertheless been less self-centred and short-sighted; they have staked their future on this, for better or for worse.
At this point, the question we find ourselves asking once again is what sort of interaction there has been between these sectors of Italian industry and the Meloni government. If we were to summarise the answer, we would say that the companies went it alone; the government failed to understand their direction and their needs. Let us not forget that the Meloni government’s first move was the ‘Made in Italy’ law, the proclamation of ‘Italian Business Day’, and the handing out of medals and promotional items at events more akin to village fairs than trade shows. Here too, Meloni has Urso as her excuse; he plays the role of ‘Minister for Pasta and Tomatoes’ to perfection, but is that enough? Or did Palazzo Chigi ultimately decide that the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR) was sufficient and, in effect, delegate responsibility for engaging with businesses to that instrument? Has it not drawn up anything resembling a plan capable of tackling the Ilva issue, or the automotive crisis, or, more generally, the competitiveness of the Italian industrial system? Giorgia Meloni, who prides herself on her ability to forge international relationships, should surely have realised, for example, that in Europe Italy needed to build an alliance with industrial nations such as Germany and Poland in order to carry weight in the balance of power in Brussels and within the Commission? Admittedly, this is just one example, but it helps to illustrate how the Prime Minister herself – who is currently whizzing round manufacturers’ meetings like a top – should have equipped herself to pursue a genuine industrial policy.
But no. Meloni thought it would be enough to forge a high-level relationship with Confindustria president Emanuele Orsini to tackle the problems facing large corporations, pocket-sized multinationals and SMEs. But in these complex times, whoever the head of the industrialists’ association might be, a top-down relationship alone would not have been enough to formulate solutions. She should have consulted industrial economists, perhaps setting up something akin to a task force at Palazzo Chigi that would provide her with a unified view of the issues and develop ‘building blocks’ of industrial policy. Tactics such as raising the thresholds for craft businesses to appease Confartigianato and CNA are short-sighted stopgap measures, certainly not a genuine policy for scaling up business. These are two distinct and divergent paths. They are mere handouts, not policy. A task force could have outlined a working hypothesis for the Italian hi-tech sector, which is grappling with Chinese competition that, since 2008, has shifted from the production of umbrellas to that of sophisticated machinery – and is therefore now competing with our mechanical engineering industry. In short, the very same Prime Minister who is visiting companies today could have put something quite different in place. Instead, she allowed the situation at Ilva to deteriorate without ever getting to the bottom of the matter, and she allowed the promise of a million cars produced in Italy to be made without an effective negotiating strategy vis-à-vis Stellantis – other than consumer incentives. It is true that the government helped Pirelli defend itself against Chinese claims, and it is also true that the sales of major companies such as Comau and Iveco were decided entirely independently by a private firm; yet 34 per cent of the household appliances sold in Italy are of Chinese origin. To what extent has Meloni contributed to the creation in Brussels of a strategy to curb Chinese exports that are replacing our own production? Yet she certainly does not lack the ambition to conceive of operations on this scale. Instead, how many times has she merely stoked anti-European resentment in assemblies – a sentiment that, needless to say, exists in large sections of Italian business and within the Confindustria leadership? The applause meter can, in some cases – notably this one – be a drug. Let Giorgia Meloni go ahead with her election tour of factories; as we have reported, she will encounter businesses that have adapted to the chaotic fluctuations of the markets, businesses that have had to fend for themselves. She should be aware, however, that in the immediate future – and she intends to remain at Palazzo Chigi for a long time – Italian industry will have to contend with energy costs (as we already know today), the lack of investment to date and competition from China. She would be well advised to develop concrete responses, convene the leading experts in the field, adopt a less suspicious stance, and, if the applause were to diminish as a result, not allow it to disconcert her.